3 ms·
I haven't suggested a definition of where to draw the line, it's exactly what I'm asking. Is that video sexual content? And how would you suggest encoding it i
by hombre_fatal 8y ago
I haven't suggested a definition of where to draw the line, it's exactly what I'm asking.
Is that video sexual content? And how would you suggest encoding it in a policy change? Obviously, "I'll know it when I see it" doesn't scale.
- nopriorarrests 8y agoI don't have an answer. But what I can tell is that video I linked above... I'll give 99% probability easily, that this video was made for purpose, with sexual context in mind, most probably by some adult person, not another kid, and it is not "just kid having fun", and it's not "family video". This is softcore erotica with 12-14 y.o. girl, and it was made to be a softcore erotica. There is literally zero other reasons to shoot video like this.
- hackinthebochs 8y agoIf you don't know anything about ASMR you might think that. But that's pretty standard content in the ASMR-sphere. The only difference is that it's being made by a preteen.
- fuzz4lyfe 8y ago>If you don't know anything about porn you might think that. But that's pretty standard content in the porn-sphere. The only difference is that it's being made by a preteen. is also true.
- hackinthebochs 8y agoSome loose similarities does not establish the sexual nature of these kind of videos.
- fuzz4lyfe 8y ago>loose similarities Without sex or nudity, how do you purpose you'd make it more similar?
- hackinthebochs 8y agoI'm not sure what you're asking. The argument was attempting to use a similarity to establish the pornographic nature of the content. My point was that a loose similarity doesn't prove his claim. Establishing a criteria for pornography is hard, but the usual metric seems relevant: designed to sexually arouse and otherwise devoid of value. But roleplay ASMR content presumably isn't designed to sexually arouse, and has other value for those who experience a physiological ASMR response from it.
- fuzz4lyfe 8y agoI can't think of a single element to add that would make it more similar to pornography without it being actual pornography. I believe that it is as similar as is possible, and getting so close cannot be accidental. I assert that if you can think of something that would make it more similar your premise that the similarity is loose may hold water, if not however it would seem that I'm correct and the similarly is uncanny.
- hackinthebochs 8y ago>I can't think of a single element to add How about explicit language? >and getting so close cannot be accidental Probably because sexual arousal and ASMR are both physiological responses.
- fuzz4lyfe 8y ago>How about explicit language? Can you point to another piece of media, say something on the Disney Channel, where adding a few curse words would turn that production from innocent children's entertainment into soft core pornography? If not why is that a unique feature to this particular video?
- darkpuma 8y ago> But that's pretty standard content in the ASMR-sphere. The "ASMR-sphere" is soft-core pornography in denial. "No you've got it all wrong, I watch it because it gives me a tingling feeling..." Yeah I'm sure it does.
- hackinthebochs 8y agoSpoken like someone who doesn't experience the physiological ASMR response. As someone who does experience it, you're obviously speaking nonsense.
- darkpuma 8y agoEven if this supposed physiological response exists, that doesn't make the content any less fundementally pornographic.
- hackinthebochs 8y agoNow you're just resorting to begging the question.
- darkpuma 8y agoI'm not interested in engaging you with formal logic. I'm making a hard assertion. This content is pornographic in nature and anybody who enjoys watching children do it is a creep who should be segregated from the rest of society.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoWhy must it scale? Laws don't have to scale. That the solution must scale algorithmically is purely for the convenience of the site, and for matters of law and taste nothing but an excuse. Even having different countries with different laws and standards doesn't scale. So what?
- int_19h 8y agoLaws have to be objective.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoYet for matters of taste, public decency, movie censorship, obscenity etc laws necessarily depend on "I'll know it when I see it" to some extent. Or you end up with absurd lists of approved and banned words, poses, bits, and "you may only reveal upto 5" above...". Objective but useless. In Florida public nudity is legal unless "vulgar or indecent". Objective how? Then we inject judges and juries into the process to make them even more subjective.
- int_19h 8y agoThat's exactly why those are all examples of bad laws.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSo how would you propose legislating them? Or are you suggesting that there should be no limit at all on what is available or permissible, or of age? Case law and precedent generally makes it clear enough, and adapts to changing expectations without needing to be rewritten. It may adapt slower than many would like. Doesn't make the laws bad. Every country has some limits, and standards for movie ratings and age restrictions etc.
- int_19h 8y agoI propose that there should be no limits on what's available or permissible that cannot be objectively defined. You can ban alcohol for people under 21, for example, but not for "people that I know when I see them shouldn't have alcohol". If you want to ban violence, you have to be specific about what this means (e.g. "no blood", "no slaying", "no physical struggle" etc). If some legislation cannot be so rewritten, it should be thrown out. Yes, that goes for anything with "vulgar" or "indecent" in the title. Speaking of standards for movie ratings - they aren't law in US, just industry guidelines. So they're subjective, but people have a choice of following them (e.g. because they believe the board that rates stuff has the same subjective opinion of what is "inappropriate" as they do) or not. Similarly, movie makers can, and do, release unrated movies. Since it's all voluntary, there's no problem here.