6 ms·
I’m not religious myself, but I think you’re letting some weird biases get in the way here. The point is that the world and the work of human beings is flawed,
by philwelch 8y ago
I’m not religious myself, but I think you’re letting some weird biases get in the way here. The point is that the world and the work of human beings is flawed, fallible, and imperfect. Whether or not heaven exists in heaven, it certainly doesn’t exist on earth and essentially never can.
- visarga 8y agoMaybe "heaven" is more like a point of view than a place. It's when ability to appreciate meets with a good situation.
- Retric 8y agoThat’s a very religious view. At most you can say humans are not what you wish them to be. Where a crystal may have ‘defects’ that’s meaningless for a pile of sand. Further, defects can be more useful than a perfect crystalline structure. So, to say perfection is unobtainable requires a strict definition of perfection and absolute proof it’s impossible. Both, are very high hurdles.
- coldtea 8y ago>That’s a very religious view. Humans are not necessarily flawed Historically they have been. At least they're not up to our own standards. We can kill, lie, cheat, brutalize, exploit, each other, and we do so daily in the billions. We might not be total bastards, but we're no perfectly fine people either.
- Retric 8y ago> We can kill, lie, cheat, brutalize, exploit, each other, and we do so daily in the billions. All of those can be very useful traits. Evolution, promotes using miliple strategies. Now, you can talk about spherical humans in a vacuum, but reality is more complex than that.
- coldtea 8y agoUseful for either the survival of the species or the individual. Still, hell for those suffering them. That's the broken part.
- Retric 8y agoWhich logically would mean it’s the universe that’s flawed not humans. Though, that gets into some very odd arguments. History would be rather boring in a static or cycling universe.
- coldtea 8y ago>Which logically would mean it’s the universe that’s flawed not humans. Logically you can argue either way. Logically one can say the universe doesn't give a fuck, so can't be flawed any more than a rock is. Humans however both crave unity and love and compassion and so on (and know those things for good), and also do the cheating, lying, killing, bullying, racism, and so on. So, one can justifyably call them broken. Heck, tons of our books, movies, and songs call us just that.
- Retric 8y ago> and know those things for good Path finding algorithms optimize for the least cost path. That does not mean such a path is good, nor a zero weight path from start to finish is perfection. In that context just because humans seek something does not inherently make it good. Religions for example often prohibit some gratifying behavior. Is an eternal state of pure bliss perfection, or little more than a drugged out meaningless existence? Individuals may prefer one state to another, but it's not clear that the state of maximized preference is thus perfection.
- PavlovsCat 8y agoIf you just squint hard enough, nothing is a flaw. "oh, this can be very useful for self-destruction and suffering, or collapsing under its own weight"
- kazagistar 8y agoFlawed compared to what? Perfect meaning what? Humans are also infamous for never being content due to constantly shifting goalposts. The reason the religious can claim imperfection is they have an "existence proof" of perfection, but I am sceptical if such a proof exists. Perhaps we can always improve and be better then we were. Which is a bit more of an optimistic statement.
- philwelch 8y agoAnd Utopianism is the notion that perfection is attainable and perhaps even inevitable if you put enough enemies of the people against the wall.
- r00fus 8y agoThe opposite of the authors viewpoint isn’t Utopianism (which is as extreme in the opposite direction) but pragmatism and realism. The fact that, flawed as we might seem, we are living in a reality that may not be possible to be more perfect.
- endominus 8y agoThe best of all possible worlds, in other words.
- r00fus 8y agoThat sounds a bit strong - I was going for "you can't verify that better worlds exist, therefore you can't say with any conviction this world is fallen unless you choose to avoid logic"
- philwelch 8y agoWhich isn’t far from an even more secular version of my point. Utopian ideologies often rely upon a superior “master race” or “new Soviet man” who has overcome the perceived imperfections and limitations of nature and who can assume a role in the world to come. In that sense, utopia itself is highly reminiscent of religious ideas, except with the addition of crucial missteps. The substantive value of the idea that humans are imperfect or “fallen” is to caution against these kinds of expectations in the first place. And there are real examples of this. It is humanly impossible—not necessarily mathematically or logically impossible, but humanly impossible—to achieve 100% success at any metric in the long run. I can’t design a 100% available distributed system at meaningful scale. An airline can’t have 100% of their planes arrive on time. A basketball player can’t make 100% of his free throws over a meaningful career. People miss, people fall short, people make mistakes, and it doesn’t require religion or Utopianism to imagine even attainable improvements. So my problem with doing away with the notion of perfection at all is that it goes too far. Will there ever be a world where no part of AWS ever has an outage? Probably not. When the next AWS outage happens, will we be able to imagine, in great detail, a world where that particular outage wouldn’t have happened? That’s the job. And so rather than resigning ourselves to the notion that perfection is meaningless, let’s instead accept that perfection is an unattainable goal. That way we can dismiss the fanatics who demand actually attaining perfection while still admitting to the possibility of improvement.
- gotocake 8y agoEven the existence of a god wouldn’t necessarily imply that a heaven could exist the way it exists in Christian theology. Frankly if you’re going to pick a religion for intellectually compelling narratives Christianity isn’t it. Gnosticism is pretty interesting, and arguably the notion of a flawed and infantile creator tracks better with both historical and various scriptural narratives. The choice of “heaven” alongside hell always struck me as an utterly naked temporal carrot and stick arrangement. “Heaven: the Coney Island of the Christian imagination.” Elbert Hubbard.
- stcredzero 8y agoThe point is that the world and the work of human beings is flawed, fallible, and imperfect. Whether or not heaven exists in heaven, it certainly doesn’t exist on earth and essentially never can. Into any system of sufficient complexity, a little suckage must come!