4 ms·
I don't understand what you find "cool": not showing protocol, not showing query parameters, or both? > Parameters at the end of web addresses are visually hid
by bambax 16y ago
I don't understand what you find "cool": not showing protocol, not showing query parameters, or both?
> Parameters at the end of web addresses are visually hidden when the address field is not focused
I think those are terrible, terrible ideas; to the best of my knowledge this behavior was pioneered by Chrome and is now growing like a cancer, under the false premise that "non-technical users don't understand urls".
How are they going to ever understand them if browsers don't show it to them??!? Hiding query parameters breaks the relation between a url and its content; now all of Google is under the same "www.google.com" url: how is that "better"?
By the same principle that "young people don't understand words" let's remove all printed words and simply print books with the same cover and the same title -- they're all "books" anyway.
- sgift 16y agoThis feature evokes unpleasant memories of Microsofts decision to hide file extensions and all the pain which came because of this. The only good news is that you can deactivate the feature in your preferences.
- pornel 16y agoI don't like that they hide query string, but they've implemented hiding of protocol well (doesn't interfere with copy&paste). I've realized that hiding of https:// https:// actually makes sense. You could mistakenly believe that page delivered over https:// https:// is secure, but there are several cases, when it's not true (e.g. page embedding JavaScript over plain HTTP). A true security indicator replacing https:// https:// in the addressbar makes more sense, and it shows secure only when connection is really secure (as far as SSL is concerned of course).
- Tomek_ 16y agoActually I wasn't referring to the fact that they hide protocol, that is indeed questionable move. What it's cool it's how they present you an information about security level of the site - check it. Edit: plus if this http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1921100 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1921100 is true (don't have Opera 11 here to check it) then hiding protocol it's hardly a problem.
- Lagged2Death 16y agoI'm sympathetic to the argument that hiding information is counter-educational. But nothing exists in a vacuum. There are serious problems to deal with, too. I suspect the concern is phishing. Consider: hxxp://mc564.mail.yahooo.cz/mc/welcome?.gx=1&.tm=1290173262&.rand=8a8hcjme2nb60#_pg=showMessage& sMid=13&&filterBy=&.rand=1020435964&midIndex=13&mid=1_41637_AFNv%2FNgAARb0TMWfVwycxVDDYoo&fromId=sendreceive@iso50.com&m=1_45237_AFRv%2FNgAALZZTMxQEQbt1QDuB60,1_44482_AFRv%2FNgAAX6dTMscRg7DzmBp0%2BM,1_43847_AFRv%2FNgAAWU6TMoFPgz8kG1tlus,1_43135_AFVv%2FNgAAPHWTMixWAJSDRUfECQ,1_42368_AFNv%2FNgAAEUnTMcCHAZk2EsgYvc,1_41637_AFNv%2FNgAARb0TMWfVwycxVDDYoo,1_40918_AFdv%2FNgAAOo%2FTMMVTQtEN0nYhxw,1_40277_AFdv%2FNgAAK2ETMGqmwMZ%2Fm865vA,1_39560_AFdv%2FNgAAJLQTMBzaQzIs28a2Uc,1_38916_AFJv%2FNgAAGfRTL97CgGm0yp6dBs,1_38170_AFZv%2FNgAAAK%2BTL4DxwdptRQfn90,&sort=date&order=down&startMid=0&hash=30c49f5b9f61273beed1953ae7674c2f&.jsrand=5917415 How likely are you to notice the problems with this URL? I'm pretty sure I wouldn't. I wouldn't be surprised to find out that non-technical users consider the address field a sort of write-only space; they type something comprehensible in there, and the browser destroys it. The simplified address field with the bold domain name is a lot easier to read, and that probably increases the chances that it will be read, rather than ignored. The full URL is just one click away.
- corin_ 16y agoEnter the URL with two spaces before it please, to place it in a code box. It's changing the layout.
- Lagged2Death 16y agoSorry about that. But that's interesting, isn't it? The URL is so unwieldy that the site and/or the typical web browser cannot handle it properly. In fact, it's so long that most of it is already invisible on a typical screen anyway.
- bambax 16y agoAll modern browsers deal with phising without destroying information; just alert the user that the site they're visiting is not what it claims to be. If users don't look at the address bar and don't understand urls, how are they going to tell something is amiss when they visit the following domains (all available at the time of writing): - gnail.fr - gnail.me - gmail.se.com - gmail.uk.net - yahooo.uk.com - yahooo.eu.com Only showing the domain does not help the non-technical user: you can have a fake domain look quite legitimate to the non-technical eye.
- famrey 16y agoWhy should people have to understand URLs? Do most people understand how the engine of a car works? No. They just want to get from A to B. Most people don't care. Hiding query parameters hides yet another thing that's mostly unreadable anyway. Comparing this to "young people don't understand words" is quite silly. Printed words are important. The message is important. And in fact, language is constantly being simplified, and has been simplified throughout history. Just like the address bar in Opera is now simplified.