3 ms·
This is a really, really, really thorny issue. On the one hand, it seems noble/responsible to suppress anti-vax, Russian influence, conspiracy theories, etc.
by crazygringo 8y ago
This is a really, really, really thorny issue.
On the one hand, it seems noble/responsible to suppress anti-vax, Russian influence, conspiracy theories, etc.
On the other hand, for centuries it's been recognized that the best antidote to "bad speech" isn't censorship, it's more speech. Don't ban, convince.
But on the other other hand, that's been exclusively argued in the domain of government action, that government censorship is ultimately worse than what it purports to cure.
In this case, tech firms/platforms like Facebook, YouTube and Pinterest aren't the government or society, they're private actors just like newspapers and members of the free press in general. Just like it could be irresponsible of the NYT to publish letters to the editor supporting anti-vax, you can argue it's equally irresponsible for tech firms to allow the same on their platforms.
Yet on the other other other hand, we're reaching a point where a great deal of discourse is concentrated on a few user-content-driven sites, so censorship on them feels like it's inching closer in spirit to government censorship.
But on the other x 4 hand, mainstream public conversation has always been driven mainly by merely a handful of newspapers and then news programs with their own editorial agendas, so a handful of tech actors exercising their own "responsible" (as self-interpreted) curation and promotion doesn't seem to be anything new.
In the end, free speech has never been an absolute right (e.g. yelling fire in a crowded theater, libel, etc.) and it's ultimately a question of finding the right balance between harms.
- pjc50 8y agoThanks to AI, it's possible to algorithmically generate almost unlimited amounts of false or meaningless speech to drown out accurate information.
- crazygringo 8y agoThanks to AI can't we also do the opposite? E.g. detect conspiracy theory speech and automatically provide relevant links/warnings to relevant curated sources?
- thfuran 8y agoThat's way, way harder.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe list of things that are true is orders of magnitude smaller than the list of things that appear true. Randomly generating plausible-looking bullshit is a thing we can do now, but ascertaining the validity of a factual statement is tantamount to solving the AGI problem.
- pjc50 8y ago"We" the public can't, but Google might. But that would require them acknowledging the problem. And once they've done that the easier solution seems to be to not recommend (which implies endorsement!) these things.
- tzs 8y ago> On the other hand, for centuries it's been recognized that the best antidote to "bad speech" isn't censorship, it's more speech. Don't ban, convince. For centuries there were fairly large barriers to widely disseminating your speech, and to lots of people having time or ability to pay attention. I think this may have limited the amount of "bad speech" that the truth had to counter. It's now a lot easier to disseminate speech, and people have more time and ability to consume speech. I probably encounter more opinions in a day now on any given topic, from people claiming to have above average or expert knowledge on them, than I did in a month a mere 40 years ago. This may make what worked centuries ago (or even a few decades ago) ineffective today.
- Pimpus 8y ago> On the other hand, for centuries it's been recognized that the best antidote to "bad speech" isn't censorship, it's more speech. Don't ban, convince. The problem with that here is that the medical industry is actually wrong. They want to censor speech because they are the bad science, and people are figuring it out. If they were right, then yes, "more speech" would be a great strategy.