3 ms·
"Toxic Workers Are More Productive" Isn't this just an instance of Berkson's paradox? [0] You might keep someone around because they're nice, or because they'
by rahimnathwani 8y ago
"Toxic Workers Are More Productive"
Isn't this just an instance of Berkson's paradox? [0]
You might keep someone around because they're nice, or because they're productive. So if they're neither nice nor productive, then they wouldn't be hired/retained. So 100% of surviving not-nice people are productive, whereas the nice people is a mix of productive and non-productive people.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkson%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkson%27s_paradox
- bduerst 8y agoI think you're talking about survivor bias, not Berkson's paradox. Also the study intentionally focuses more on the cost-benefit of retaining a specific population - productive toxic people - and doesn't care about non-productive (toxic or non-toxic) people since they don't factor into that specific C/B equation.
- shkkmo 8y agoI think the reference to Berkson's paradox is spot on: > The most common example of Berkson's paradox is a false observation of a negative correlation between two positive traits, i.e., that members of a population which have some positive trait tend to lack a second. Berkson's paradox occurs when this observation appears true when in reality the two properties are unrelated—or even positively correlated—because members of the population where both are absent are not equally observed. But you are also correct, survivor bias can lead to Berkson's paradox.
- ThePadawan 8y agoYou might also keep someone around because there are not enough candidates to fill all positions, never mind hire a replacement for them.