4 ms·
Password managers are universally terrible, but until security experts stop telling people to use them, everyone's going to dump their sensitive passwords into
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
Password managers are universally terrible, but until security experts stop telling people to use them, everyone's going to dump their sensitive passwords into incredibly poor apps written to put all your access in one place secured by one single password.
A lot of password advice today is bad. You only should be making valuable passwords (those that control sensitive data or access) unique. Forum accounts do not need that level of security and you waste cognitive power by doing so.
Banks, email accounts, and a handful of others are the only ones worth truly securing. And passphrases can be incredibly easy to remember, unlike passwords.
- ubercow13 8y agoHow is it more secure to have a passphrase in your head? If an attacker is in a position to exploit your password manager in the way described in this paper, they are in a position to sniff your bank password as soon as you type it
- hombre_fatal 8y ago> Forum accounts do not need that level of security Though it's also in the platform's best interest to defend itself from weak passwords because there are usually a lot more defenses against fresh accounts than existing accounts that get taken over. We're seeing websites becoming more and more proactive here like rejecting passwords that appear on haveibeenpwned. Also, I recognize your username from your extreme stance against password managers in the past and you seem to make the mistake of not acknowledging trade-offs. I think it weakens your point, especially when talking about end-user security where 90%+ of people are reusing passwords, not debating whether they should use a password manager or roll their own physical password pad scheme. If you reject current password managers, can you envision a digital solution that would satisfy you?
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoWhy is a "digital solution" a requirement? Storing all your passwords on a computer, or worse, in the cloud, will never be a good solution.
- Fnoord 8y ago> You only should be making valuable passwords (those that control sensitive data or access) unique. I have access on a forum where if I log out it asks shows me my sessions, including my IP address. My IP address is PII. I have my e-mail address hidden on this forum as well. My e-mail address is PII. I have ordered something on AliExpress. My physical address can be found by logging in to my account. I actually have multiple addresses on my eBay account where some can save me some costs due to being in a different country. And if anyone logs in to my account on AliExpress, they'd be able to log in on that other forum or eBay as well if it weren't for a password manager. My password manager allows me to make a passphrase, btw. The terrible thing about a passphrase is it takes long to type it, and a typo takes even longer. I prefer a YubiKey plus a decent PIN though it doesn't work very well against a hostile government.
- dontbenebby 8y ago>Banks, email accounts, and a handful of others are the only ones worth truly securing. And passphrases can be incredibly easy to remember, unlike passwords. You could also use one long passphrase for your password manager that even a state level adversary probably can't crack: https://theintercept.com/2015/03/26/passphrases-can-memorize-attackers-cant-guess/ https://theintercept.com/2015/03/26/passphrases-can-memorize... Edit: To be clear, one passphrase for your password manager not 1 passphrase used on every site.