5 ms·
There are a few practices in modern agriculture that are probably not helping. Farmers use pesticides to kill everything but the crop they are interested in. Th
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
There are a few practices in modern agriculture that are probably not helping. Farmers use pesticides to kill everything but the crop they are interested in. Then they use pesticides to get rid of insects and other parasites, and finally they use herbicides so they can trigger plants to start dying just in time for harvest rather than waiting this to happen organically.
That stuff is nasty. It's actually intended to be nasty. And the side effect is that it kills a lot of animals and plants indiscriminately. Also, this stuff is possibly not that great for human consumption either. There seems to be a lot of lobbying around this topic and a lot of debate about what is considered OK here. But I'd say most people would probably opt out of having any of this stuff in their food, just on the off chance it might decrease their chances of getting some cancer, genetic defects in their offspring, etc.
Modern organic farming can actually get great yields by more clever use of soil and land and does not need pesticides, herbicides, or insecticides. There is a lot of high tech stuff facilitating this including drones, water management, use of herds of animals to manage soil (planned grazing), etc. And then there is hydroponic farming as well. Progress in this space is very rapid.
Phasing these out and restricting the use of poison in farming would probably be a good thing. This cannot be done over night but there are plenty of farms that have switched to being fully organic while increasing yields and profits. It can be done and it requires doing things differently. Now is a good time to start doing much more of that. And we might actually restore some arid lands to healthy condition in the process which would not hurt our planet either.
- jki275 8y agoI'd love to see a citation on this -- my impression (grew up in farm country) was that organic farming was significantly less yield, higher expense, and totally impossible to actually run a profitable farm on without raising prices immensely. People do it, but the market for food that costs 3x is relatively small -- most moderate to lower income simply can't afford it. Maybe things have changed, but I suspect if they have everybody would have switched already. Obviously getting rid of poisons is a great target, but I've never heard from anyone in the business that it's even a possibility.
- circlefavshape 8y agoOrganic products are often more expensive, but not necessarily 3x more expensive, or anywhere near it Carrots for sale in Ireland in one of the most popular supermarkets - https://www.tesco.ie/groceries/product/search/default.aspx?searchBox=carrots https://www.tesco.ie/groceries/product/search/default.aspx?s... ... organic ones are more or less the same price as non-organic
- jki275 8y agoI was thinking of the most common organic thing we buy, which are eggs -- usually about .69usd/dozen for the regular ones and 2.99-3.99usd/dozen for the organic ones. I'm sure there are many other things one could look at, but in general at the stores where I shop it's around that. ETA: Logically, the comment doesn't make sense anyway -- farmers like money, they're not ideologically hanging on to spraying their crops with unnecessary poisons because they want to.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoMany years since I had relatives in agriculture and horticulture, so I may be embarrasingly outdated. Monoculture tends to encourage everything we don't want. Needing fertilisers or rotation, pesticides, disease has many acres to spread easily through etc. There's good organic and bad, and efficient and inefficient., but look into polyculture[1]. An old mixed farm would mix crops and sometimes livestock in the same space. The yields were lower, but there were often more yields across the farm to compensate. Thus the yield difference is often not as advertised. Sympathetic planting could actively reduce likelihood of disease and pests. Not everything scales to large farms. It's also expensive because it's expensive. People expect and treat organic as a premium product. Supermarkets charge accordingly, in no small part because they can. If less industrial approaches to agriculture became widespread, prices would fall. Though unlikely to remove the difference completely. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyculture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyculture (Doesn't consider organic polyculture)
- gph 8y ago>there are plenty of farms that have switched to being fully organic while increasing yields and profits. But probably not corn or any of the other staple crops. It's going to be hard to get the same yields of those without using modern industrial monoculture techniques.
- doctorpangloss 8y agoWe don't actually know if profits in real farms rise as much as agricultural tech sellers say they do. Bayer and Monsanto could just have really good sales teams. (They obviously do). Like with medicine, we'd expect the effects measured in lab of new pesticides on yields to be larger than their real impact in the wild. It just receives considerably less scrutiny than medicine, so really, it's hard to cut through all the bullshit. Despite what anyone's feel good story may bring up in rebuttal, there really isn't that much talent going into the buy-side of agricultural technology. So what if it turns out that industrial monoculture techniques are vastly oversold (they almost certainly are), and that the real math shows a slight benefit, but not one that outweighs environmental costs?
- gph 8y ago>So what if it turns out that industrial monoculture techniques are vastly oversold (they almost certainly are) Maybe some of the more recent techniques of industrial monoculture are oversold, but the steady rise of yields since the 1940s [1] make me feel like you're talking up a much bigger game than is actually the case. Perhaps the cost of some of Monsantos latest GMOs and pesticides isn't worth it. But throwing out the entire industrial monoculture paradigm is absolutely not cost effective. If it was more farmers would have figured it out by now. They aren't that dumb. [1] https://www.agry.purdue.edu/ext/corn/news/timeless/images/CornYieldTrend_US.gif https://www.agry.purdue.edu/ext/corn/news/timeless/images/Co...
- AngryData 8y agoMost of corn and other staple crops large yields have more to do with the excessive usage of fossil fuel derived fertilizer. There have been some gains in GMO to get slightly more efficient yields, but we already spent a few thousand years doing that by hand selection so any extra gains are pretty difficult. What we have largely been focusing on is making the plants resistant to pesticides so that the inevitable infection doesn't occur while you are dumping on crazy amounts of freely available energy as fertilizer. Basically we are turning natural gas into food, 60% of the worlds total crop yield in fact exists because of natural gas derived fertilizer, and when nature tries to take it's share of that free energy, we dump anything we can on it to prevent it from infecting our crops. Pump and dump the soil like that for 20 years until it is garbage, sell it off, buy out some poor struggling farmer that is doing sustainable practices, start over again with fresh 50-100 year maintained topsoil.
- gbrown 8y agoHerbicides for dessication seem like a terrible, terrible idea. If I wanted glyphosate to end up in food, that's what I'd do.