9 ms·
Pinterest Blocks Vaccination Searches in Move to Control the Conversation
- kennbutler 8y agoI still feel like large tech companies don't understand the amount of power they wield beyond it's capacity to influence buying decisions. I personally believe that YouTube (pre-2009) was the early breeding ground for conspiracy theorists, and Facebook groups/pages was the enriched gasoline added to the fire.
- Nasrudith 8y agoThe question is a bit philosophical at this point given the boundaries but is it truly their power? The spread was by "Conspiracy Theorists" types look for self confirmation first to others of the type. It isn't like they could do anything to say get them to support say sensible infastructure upgrades because it wouldn't flatter their egos. YouTube rewind got critically panned and any overt efforts for youtube tend to be poorly received.
- pjc50 8y agoThe recommendation engine plays a very big role. Fundamentally the ad companies (FGA) have a problem - their entire value proposition is that the little space at the side of the page and before the content is very valuable and has an influence on people's thoughts and decisions. So if they then try to claim that the content itself, or the list of recommended "watch next" videos on Youtube, isn't influential, it fails the sniff test. (Apple are mostly clear on this front. Netflix know the "watch next" is critical to their success, but they don't let people fill it with unvetted garbage.)
- helen___keller 8y agoPre 2009? Is this not true today?
- kadendogthing 8y agoOur society is so obsessed with the fear of censorship, or the "elite" hoarding all information, that we've now dived right into the opposite deep end. There's always too much of a good thing. We created tech to usher in an era of new mediums. But we never stopped to ask ourselves what should we keep from the "old" systems. In any system that gets recreated/refactored, there is always a duplication of efforts. And that's what we're seeing right now. We're slowly realizing that editorialization is desperately needed. In all these social graphs that's been created, we assume all "nodes" are rational actors, or are likely to be rational actors and that the information if just let free would steadily sort itself out. But that's not what we're seeing. Old diseases are new again and entire republics have fallen victim to misinformation. It's well past time to address these issues. I thought 2008 was bad. I could have never imagine 2016. And now I'm severely worried about what non-sense we'll see in 2020. Tech companies, and the employees in these companies, need to continually ask themselves what they're empowering. EDIT: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PMotykw0SIk&feature=youtu.be&t=1282 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PMotykw0SIk&feature=youtu.be...
- tdb7893 8y agoMy father in law is a conspiracy theorist and it came a lot more from Fox News and talk radio than YouTube. They were pretty mainstream well before YouTube
- sandworm101 8y agoThe difference was that 1990s conspiracies were all about secret government agencies doing secret stuff in secret places. Modern conspiracies are out in public. Pizzagate, still belived by many, is different than area 51. This visibility means belief is constantly reenforced.
- tdb7893 8y agoMost of the people I've talked to aren't crazy alien conspiracy theorists so I can't really comment on that brand of conspiracy theorist. Honestly my main experience is the standard 9/11, global warming, and Obama conspiracy theories (which were incredibly racist) from the early to mid 2000s and those were all pretty similar to modern theories and at least for my father in law and his friends were definitely from Fox News and talk radio. Edit: a good example to me was the start of the birther movement, which is a quinessential modern conspiracy theory to me, and I remember that as talk radio and Fox News.
- sandworm101 8y agoGlobal warming and birtherism were a turning point. It was then than condpiracy theories were directly applicable to politics. Managing them then became a practical political weapon.
- EamonnMR 8y agoThe John Birch Society predates both, and was a similar movement by similar people towards similar ends.
- travisoneill1 8y agoEveryone is saying this, but is there actually a measured increase in belief in conspiracy theories? I have only ever seen it stated as an assumption.
- andrewclunn 8y agoLet me guess, in 12 months they'll be burying factually accurate information about unintended side effects from new vaccines under the guise of thus being promotion of "anti-vaxxer conspiracies."
- duxup 8y agoSome firms are more on top of it than others. Netflix's deal with Goop is not encouraging, Goop just a "lifestyle brand" that is selling snake oil.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIn the end they will always go for more money despite all the talk about values.
- abakker 8y agoWell, I feel like it is also worth pointing out that all money starts to be a lot more persuasive when your business model is "lose other people's money until a miracle occurs". Honestly, if we have a system which permits/encourages sky-high valuations and seemingly interesting businesses to expand well beyond their user's desires or ability to pay, this is precisely what we get. If you monetize on ads, you need damn expensive ads. If you want to have expensive ads, you gotta do something to actually make them work. if sustainability vs valuation was a goal, then there might be more incentive to avoid these kinds of odd, consumer hostile behaviors. Users may not be the product, but, they're not the direct revenue source either. As long as ads can trick people into clicking, there is an incentive to charge for those ads.
- bduerst 8y agoIt's not all vapid nonsense - people are now tying branding to their personal identity more (probably as a side effect of social media, but I digress). If a person feels a consumer-facing company doesn't align with their values then they won't be a customer.
- nabnob 8y agoThis is incredibly worrying. I understand that anti-vax conspiracy theories are dangerous, but I can think of a ton of ways banning "bad medical advice", as determined by a $10/hr contractor at Pinterest, Facebook, etc. could end up hurting people with health problems by preventing them from sharing useful information. I have gender dysphoria and at one point considered getting on testosterone, but thanks to conversations with transmen and detransitioned women on social media, I learned about less-commonly discussed side effects and decided against taking testosterone. This is an area where research is still developing and there aren't a ton of long-term studies, so it's incredibly helpful to be able to learn from other people's experiences, even if they aren't yet confirmed by research. Likewise, I know people who've had a post or comment removed by Facebook because it was erroneously interpreted as racist or sexist. Off the top of my head, I know a friend who was sharing information on ICE raids with friends who were immigrants and they got banned from Facebook for a couple of hours (he was unbanned after appealing). I know someone else who was sharing statistics on domestic violence that was interpreted as discriminatory. The corporations making these policies don't have a good enough understanding of political issues to determine whether a statement is hate speech - and hell, even people who are knowledgeable about politics and history disagree in a lot of areas.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI agree. It worries me that public conversation gets policed by companies whose main goal is to sell ads to the highest bidder. By definition they will have to prefer information that makes them money over information that doesn’t make them money. They are also very vulnerable to pressure from governments. In addition you have no real recourse if the big machine doesn’t like what you posted.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- C1sc0cat 8y agoThis is true but its more stopping scammers / snake oil salespersons selling placebo's to desperate people. I few years ago I reported (to Matt Cuts) people using ppc selling snake oil pills to people with chronic organ failure by buying ppc on the medication keywords that people like me where using.
- srkmno 8y agoMore like the next frontier in which legacy media companies are going to attempt to generate ill will towards internet companies and suggest they should apply censorship or be censored by governments.
- darkerside 8y agoThe cure for bad information is usually more information.
- darkerside 8y agoExpanding on my own post... why is it any tech company's responsibility to protect people from their own bad decisions?
- pixl97 8y agoAre you serious? Because as of so far, in the US, the law demands it. Look at every product you buy "Don't do X dangerous thing with said device". We regulate countless things that can be physically harmful to individuals. I can't go to the store and by dynamite because I can harm myself and others with it. So should information be regulated if it can cause physical harm to oneself and others. This is not an easy question to answer.
- darkerside 8y agoSo law should dictate what we're able to say? There was a time when that was counter to the entire point.
- ijpoijpoihpiuoh 8y agoLegal responsibility, or moral? The answer is of course "it depends," in this case on who you ask. Maybe they don't even think it's their responsibility, but they think it will make life better for their customers. I personally do a lot of things that aren't my responsibility, but which I think are good to do for various other reasons.
- darkerside 8y agoThat makes sense in cases where you know what's best for others.
- nisten 8y ago
- crazygringo 8y agoThis is a really, really, really thorny issue. On the one hand, it seems noble/responsible to suppress anti-vax, Russian influence, conspiracy theories, etc. On the other hand, for centuries it's been recognized that the best antidote to "bad speech" isn't censorship, it's more speech. Don't ban, convince. But on the other other hand, that's been exclusively argued in the domain of government action, that government censorship is ultimately worse than what it purports to cure. In this case, tech firms/platforms like Facebook, YouTube and Pinterest aren't the government or society, they're private actors just like newspapers and members of the free press in general. Just like it could be irresponsible of the NYT to publish letters to the editor supporting anti-vax, you can argue it's equally irresponsible for tech firms to allow the same on their platforms. Yet on the other other other hand, we're reaching a point where a great deal of discourse is concentrated on a few user-content-driven sites, so censorship on them feels like it's inching closer in spirit to government censorship. But on the other x 4 hand, mainstream public conversation has always been driven mainly by merely a handful of newspapers and then news programs with their own editorial agendas, so a handful of tech actors exercising their own "responsible" (as self-interpreted) curation and promotion doesn't seem to be anything new. In the end, free speech has never been an absolute right (e.g. yelling fire in a crowded theater, libel, etc.) and it's ultimately a question of finding the right balance between harms.
- pjc50 8y agoThanks to AI, it's possible to algorithmically generate almost unlimited amounts of false or meaningless speech to drown out accurate information.
- crazygringo 8y agoThanks to AI can't we also do the opposite? E.g. detect conspiracy theory speech and automatically provide relevant links/warnings to relevant curated sources?
- thfuran 8y agoThat's way, way harder.
- raphlinus 8y agoThis isn't their first rodeo. In 2008 Google launched Knol, which was a fairly major initiative to provide a service like Wikipedia, but without Wikipedia's problems around unattributed content. The idea was that authors would post with their professional affiliation, and get compensated with ad revenue. They hoped to attract actual medical professionals, as medicine was one of the areas where you want to be able to rely on the information. It failed miserably. The incentives were favorable to spammers but not to actual professionals. No real expert would invest their time into the platform, putting their reputation on the line, for a few paltry ad dollars. But there were some people who mastered cranking out low quality content. I'm not making any claims about the new effort, just pointing out that identifying a problem and putting resources behind a solution is often not enough.
- oxymoran 8y agoCan they finish their other wars first?
- existentialhalt 8y agoWhen the medical system actually starts curing people then they can claim their advice is the best. Otherwise it's just opinion. If you can't cure a disease you don't understand it.