3 ms·
Fighting Cybercrime – What Happens to the Law When the Law Cannot Be Enforced?
- gcb0 8y agoso much bullshit to force new abusive legislation. at least they avoided "think of the children"itis nothing on this topic is new. laws for wire fraud and money laundry already lay a foundation for prosecuting international crimes. the problem is one of three groups (us-eu-jp-au, Russia, China) selectively enforcing prosecution for whatever reasons. new legislation will change nothing.
- harimau777 8y agoIf it is impossible to enforce laws against cybercrimes, one option would be to bring back the concept of outlawery: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outlaw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outlaw Once a jury finds that a given domain was responsible for a crime but it was impossible to actually go after them, the government would declare them to be a fair target for any hackers. Note: I don't know if this would actually be a good idea. I just think its an interesting idea.
- TACIXAT 8y agoA principle that is discussed is hacking back. It actually almost passed in Georgia, USA. [1] The idea would be that if something was attacking you, you could go on the offense to disrupt it. Personally, I think that would be a lot of fun. 1. https://threatpost.com/georgia-governor-vetoes-controversial-hack-back-bill/131822/ https://threatpost.com/georgia-governor-vetoes-controversial...
- jstarfish 8y agoIt almost passed in Georgia because our legislators are idiots. They also almost passed a law criminalizing security research altogether. The problem with allowing open season is that unlike the wild west, outlaws did not literally hijack the bodies of victims to masquerade as someone else before engaging in criminal activity. The "hacker" you're attacking is usually another victim of the operator serving as a proxy. Attribution in the cybersecurity space is very difficult and prone to error. You'd just be institutionalizing lynch mobs.
- saiya-jin 8y agoYou can just submit TLS certificate revocation and web would stop working pretty quickly with most modern browsers. Or get them removed from DNS network for a quick death. The problem is, morals are relative - one country/judge/group of people can find something breaking the local law, while being OK somewhere else, ie in place of actual location of servers. Who will decide what is OK to punish and what not? Half of the world would have issues with western (ie US) view on things, we can say the same about west vs some african/arab dictatorship.
- michaelt 8y agoThere are certainly cybercrimes that could be much better enforced. Running DDoS botnets of insecure network cameras, distributing ransomware, making robocalls, revenge porn, and so on. But there's another set of cybercrimes where I don't really care about enforcement. Running Sci-Hub, bypassing DRM to refill inkjet printer cartridges, violating superinjunctions, and suchlike. Sadly, the latter set tends to have much better lobbyists than the former, so I'm always nervous about the outcome of legislators attempting to improve the law.
- jstarfish 8y ago> revenge porn I've always wondered why USC 2257 is never pulled out to deal with this. It seems like the sort of law enacted to allow arbitrary punishment of porn producers-- just find some fault in their paperwork to wreck their day. An angry ex with your honeymoon tape has no such paperwork at all.
- stebann 8y agoLaw can't be enforced because some powers don't want that. What about money laundering that could get hidden within seemingly legit transactions for multi billon dollars companies? Wouldn't be abusive if they try to regulate the behaviour of people buying online? How do they know the way to conduct that kind of investigation? Doesn't seem realistic.
- craftinator 8y agoIt erodes the authority of the lawmaker.
- jdsully 8y agoI always thought the way we talk about "unsecured" services was wrong. I leave my door unlocked all the time and have no expectation someone will come by and test it. Were they to see it unlocked they'd have no expectation they were allowed in. If someone does break in nobody suggests it was because their choice of lock was "weak". I don't expect I'd ever see it in my lifetime, but I would love to live in a world where people don't try random ssh passwords thousands of times a day against my servers. Being on the internet is like living in a bad neighborhood.