3 ms·
That's no different to conventional history and culture. It just has computers in it. Dyson seems to have only just worked out that evolution, culture, and pol
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
That's no different to conventional history and culture. It just has computers in it.
Dyson seems to have only just worked out that evolution, culture, and politics are emergent.
Which is why the argument makes no sense. Either digital systems add something new and unique to the mix, or they don't.
If they don't, then what's the point of the piece?
If they do, blather about analog metazoans is irrelevant. The problem becomes one of understanding emergence without obfuscation and hand-waving.
In fact so-called emergent behaviour is not the problem. Not even slightly.
The biggest digital systems we have now have been consciously and deliberately designed to monitor and manipulate human behaviour.
There's nothing emergent, surprising, obscure, or quasi-mystical about either the outline goals or the specific techniques used to achieve them.
Instead of resorting to obscurantism, it would be far more useful to invent a new kind of "digital democracy" where the goals of large software corporations were open to democratic oversight.
Of course that's not going to happen while free market excuses and rhetoric are used to keep democratic oversight well away from these corporations.
- twtw 8y ago> no different to conventional history and culture. It just has computers in it. I would argue that it is different, because it has computers in it. > The biggest digital systems we have now have been consciously and deliberately designed to monitor and manipulate human behaviour. They've been designed to make users click on this or that or watch or scroll more, but I disagree that all the consequences of those designs were or are understood. I don't think anyone intentionally designed a system to make kids watch creepy YouTube videos endlessly or not get vaccinated or think the earth is flat, they designed a system to "maximize engagement" and these things happened (maybe or not as a consequence).
- armitron 8y agoThere is this concept of emergent control called a "metasystem transition" [1] which is what Dyson is really talking about. Conventional history and culture has never before been shaped by the - ever shortening, ever accelerating - techonomic feedback loops that we see today. Cybernetics has been summoned like Yog Sothoth in "The case of Charles Dexter Ward". [1] http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/MST.html http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/MST.html [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_of_Charles_Dexter_Ward https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Case_of_Charles_Dexter_War...
- dexen 8y ago>Which is why the argument makes no sense. Either digital systems add something new and unique to the mix, or they don't. I'm sorry but this runs counter the observed historical reality. For reference, consider data transmission interfaces (USB, SCSI, memory busses, display interfaces, etc): "Is parallel better than serial? Is serial better than parallel?". The history clearly indicates that, every few generation of interfaces there's a big switch-over between parallel and serial, and back, and fore again. The approaches simply have different trade-offs, and at different point of evolution of our understanding and available technology it makes sense to pick one over another. Neither of them is inherently "ultimately better". Likewise digital vs analog computing. It used to be[1] that analog (calculations and computations) ruled the day. In case we forgot already, there were not only analog (mechanical and electrical and electronic) programmable computers and fixed-function, complex calculators, but many an everyday object are analog electronic calculators in time and frequency domains. Cue the humble superheterodyne radio, and the analog color TV. Cybernetics used to be a thing, too. Then came the digital electronic computation, which allowed us to translate lambda-calculus theory verbatim into discrete bits (sorry!) of control words and data. However digital is a leaky abstraction over switching electronics [2]; all the transistors aren't digital, and - Moore's law notwithstanding - digital view of analog semiconductors is modern equivalent of squaring a circle. Or describing astronomy with ever more epicycles. It works, but at the cost of the ever-growing complexity, and a bit of suspension of disbelief. We already are having renaissance of continuous-valued computation: the present day crop of early quantum computers. Both the computing elements (quantum gates) and also the control programs and data are in the complex number domain. On the other end of the spectrum, we're using ever more neural networks, which are analog abstractions over our digital computers. At some point somebody will start asking questions. Maybe even invent (or make feasible) the long-awaited memristor. I'm sure we'll be shifting back to digital in a few decades though. -- [1] glossing over discrete computation approach of the early pioneers like Charles Babbage [2] and switching electronics, whether semiconducting or valve-based, is merely a leaky abstraction over high-gain analog amplification, but I digress