3 ms·
Welcome to the post-information world. We're going to have to get used to this new reality. Just as those living in the era before recorded pictures or words d
by echelon 8y ago
Welcome to the post-information world.
We're going to have to get used to this new reality. Just as those living in the era before recorded pictures or words didn't have reliable records to lean on, we'll grow to distrust all of the things that are posted. This will happen naturally as the volume of fakes increases; people will start to develop a doubtfulness around recorded media.
I don't think we need to worry about propaganda and fake news if the Facebooks and Instagrams become flooded with fake posts from the people we know. It'll become expected and mundane. This seems good for the development of a skeptical public.
When we do need to rely on audiovisual records, such as for court cases, we'll have experts that can investigate and verify.
- entee 8y agoPerhaps as a byproduct we'll end up with more value placed on human-curated and generated information. Just because there's a lot of noise in the world doesn't mean there aren't objective truths. If FB and Insta get shunted off as sources of news, maybe the good ones will be all that remains trusted. Dare to dream.
- komali2 8y agoThe idea of Reputation Economy, yea? Combined with the need for good technology that "guarantees" that https://www.washingtonpost.com https://www.washingtonpost.com really is the washington post. Reminds me of that theory of the mind stuff around trying to figure out if we're really brains in jars or not - we need to find ways to measure our trust of the source, and the means by which the source is transmitted to us.
- zanny 8y agoI wanted to suggest a crypto enclave built into recording devices that could sign recordings with private keys controlled by the manufacturer but even that wouldn't be too hard to circumvent by piping fake images/audio into such an enclave so long as you have hardware access.
- TomMarius 8y agoThen maybe we've found the limit of miniaturisation - this could mean that we need devices that could be routinely inspected by the users, hardware-wise. Maybe not every device owned by a person would be like that - this would be something you keep in your safe.
- intended 8y ago>if the Facebooks and Instagrams become flooded with fake posts from the people we know. It'll become expected and mundane. This seems good for the development of a skeptical public. This is not how people or trust networks work. What you are looking at is a sliver of human behavior- the silver lining on the cloud. Most people instead will be confused, believe incorrect things, get frustrated when it’s wrong and then begin to trust their gut instincts in an information poor environment. It would be very natural for people in this scenario to switch to old school centralized trust and truth organizations like clans, states and nations. People need to understand the world and we regularly pay money to find out truth. Investigation takes time and when the rate at which we can make believable content outstrips the rate at which investigators can be hired to debunk it, then even courts can’t keep up - which happens today. FurhTher by leaving it to just the courts we also are saying that the casual consumer will not have access to a safe internet. I argued yesterday that Chinese style great firewalls seem to be the likely model for our future, as opposed to the future democracies hoped to create.
- echelon 8y agoThis view of the future is based in fear. We don't need to be "protected" by big brother. Let's see how it plays out.
- intended 8y agoCalling it based on fear or based on optimism is a luxury of the disconnected. I am telling you how it is currently playing out on the ground in chat rooms, forums, facebook, Twitter and elsewhere, because I worked part time on moderating these places and saw first hand what was going on. I’ve spoken to people who do policy for FAANGs and with activists on the ground. This is what is happening, and has happened in third world countries and developing nations without the man power to investigate most crimes. This is a genuine concern - as long as engagement driven social media exists.