9 ms·
Self-Driving Cars Might Kill Auto Insurance as We Know It
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 8y agoUnlikely. Car owners will still need liability insurance, lenders will require comprehensive, collision, and uninsured motorist coverage to protect their collateral. These coverages should in theory get less expensive if claims drop, but profit margin on the policies doesn't necessarily change.
- riskneutral 8y ago> Car owners will still need liability insurance Legal liability will shift to the manufacturers, therefore individuals will not require insurance. Insurance policies will be purchased by the manufacturers and will cover the entire fleet under one policy. > coverages should in theory get less expensive if claims drop This is certainly the largest factor, as insured losses are expected to drop by 90%. A secondary factor will be that car manufacturers will be able to negotiate wholesale “group policies” on large fleets and get a better rate. Or they could self-insure and cut out the insurance industry completely. > but profit margin on policies doesn’t necessarily change I have already noted the profit margin pressure arising due to wholesale fleet insurance / self-insurance. But the more important point is that profit margin is not the only relevant measure for an industry. The total amount of revenue is equally important. If profit margins stay the same but revenues decrease, then there is a reduction in net income. Note that prices are expected to fall 90%, which directly impacts revenue.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Legal liability will shift to the manufacturers No, it probably won't. Owners will probably remain liable in the first instance, for maintaining th vehicle in a safe operating condition; manufacturers (and the whole chain of commerce) will be liable, as they are now, for defects that exist at the time of sale, and will be (as they are now) attractive deep-pockets defendants. But, for that reason, they will probably get very good at playing off failures (since drivers aren't in the picture to blame) as maintenance failures rather manufacturing defects.
- riskneutral 8y agoNo, it probably will. In the same way that you are not liabile for any accidents if you are a passenger in a taxi. It will take some time for legal scholars to work out all the details (e.g. gross negligence, etc), but it is very obvious that passengers in fully autonomous vehicles cannot be legally liable to the same extent that drivers are liable today.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> In the same way that you are not liabile for any accidents if you are a passenger in a taxi. A passenger is neither an owner, an operator, nor a manufacturer of a taxi. Owners, operators, and manufacturers tend to be liable; passengers not under normal circumstances. If I get hit by a bus (to escape the taxi situation where the operator is usually the owner), the bus driver, bus line, and bus manufacturer can all be liable. Replacing the operator with a piece of equipment manufactured by the manufacturer and maintained by the owner takes the driver out of the equation, but there is no logical reason why it would remove liability from the owner.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- taurath 8y agoThe concept of "Owners" is an interesting one in the context of self-driving, manufacturer-insured vehicles. I'd imagine that self-diagnostics would have to get very very good to the point of not starting when a single sensor is unavailable - nobody would want to ride in "their" car if it has a chance of causing a crash and them being legally liable despite not driving it.
- gamblor956 8y agoBut, for that reason, they will probably get very good at playing off failures (since drivers aren't in the picture to blame) as maintenance failures rather manufacturing defects. Manufacturers already do that now...Ford was doing that back in the Pinto days. The change to self-driving cars will make maintenance (and maintenance records) more important for drivers for liability purposes, but will also make it more difficult for the manufacturers to avoid liability.
- decebalus1 8y ago> Legal liability will shift to the manufacturers Nah.. Manufacturers will even invest heavily in lobby efforts for this to never happen. Even if consumers will likely not own the car as they currently do (see the growing trend that you're not actually owning the car but you're paying for the license to use it indefinitely) they will be responsible for keeping it running will be the de-facto 'operators' regardless if the car is driving itself. The car will probably not store itself, not maintain/clean itself, will not keep it's radars/cameras active and not blocked by dirt/snow/etc.. Call me a pessimist but the consumers will likely get shafted.
- kardos 8y ago> Call me a pessimist but the consumers will likely get shafted. You're a pessimist! Actually I don't see that there would be much difference. The car will perform at some level of skill and have an associated risk, lets say that amounts to $50/mo. The customer could pay the manufacturer to pay the insurance company, or the customer could pay directly -- same thing?
- riskneutral 8y agoThe end game is that almost no one will own a car, and most people will use fully autonomous taxis for transportation. If and when fully autonomous vehicles become a reality, auto insurance will die along with car ownership and parking lots.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoI see little reason to suppose that that will be the end game. Those for whom the total cost of ownership of a car are lower than the cost of taxis will continue to own a car. What fraction of people that currently own cars will that be? Probably depends on where you live. Taxi will probably never be the popular choice in, say, South Dakota. The economics just don't work out.
- stormbrew 8y agoThe cost of autonomous cars, especially in terms of maintenance, is likely to be higher. And autonomous taxis will be cheaper to operate because drivers are a very expensive part of them. The number of people for whom owning a car makes sense will definitely go down when prices on cars rise and prices on taxis and public transportation drop. This is ignoring the fact that having an unproductive self driving car sitting in your garage becomes a significant opportunity cost itself.
- randyrand 8y ago> Legal liability will shift to the manufacturers Why? If you're operating a vehicle with known and manufacturer specified risks, thats on you.
- gamblor956 8y agoIt's basic product liability law. The liability is actually on both the owner and the manufacturer (and the dealer, and anyone else involved in that chain of transactions...). And as the deeper pocket, realistically the liability is all on the manufacturer.
- sadris 8y agoYou're not operating a vehicle. You're a passenger in a vehicle operated by waymo.
- gambiting 8y agoI thought we were talking about your own vehicles. If you own a self driving vehicle, and it crashes because you neglected maintenance then that's on the owner not manufacturer, just like it is with existing cars.
- dagw 8y agoSure, but what if I had done all the maintenance I was supposed to and it crashes. Should that still be on me or on Waymo? I wonder self driving car manufacturers are going to try to get around this making the required maintenance and 'pre-flight' check list so onerous that basically nobody is completely in compliance and thus they're never responsible.
- gambiting 8y agoYes, if you drive around and suddenly your spring coil breaks making you swerve and hit someone else, that's still on you, even if you have followed the maintenance booklet precisely. You can't sue the manufacturer for that, they will just say the part has worn out and you were supposed to spot that(somehow, even though the law requires an annual inspection at best).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- i_am_proteus 8y agoIt would be very simple for manufacturers of autonomous cars to obviate the question of "who is liable" for a collision by simply loading insurance into the price of the vehicle. Extremely easy to price into a lease; less obvious but still eminently feasible with a sale.
- Shivetya 8y agoI am going to go with, not until they get all non self driving cars off the road. Until then during the transition it will become a lawsuit paradise until the regulations are settled as any crash involving a self driving car with a person driven car will be challenged with boasts of class action suits and more. a large portion of my current insurance is for uninsured motorist and under insured though my agent says the former is by far the biggest issue. considering law enforcement isn't making much head way there and true self driving isn't going to happen soon except under theme park ride conditions I don't think insurance is going anywhere.
- arcaster 8y agoI completely disagree - seems like pricing insurance for self driving vehicles competitively would be a great way to ensure more people transition to self driving vehicles rather than conventional vehicles.
- quxbar 8y agoI assume I'll have to buy insurance to go into 'manual' mode for a few minutes at a time, the price fluctuating according to the time, where I'm driving, and a possible breathalyzer-style test ;)
- mikeash 8y agoHouse insurance still exists, despite the fact that the rate of collisions caused by human error is zero. I’m sure premiums would change considerably, but “kill”?
- saagarjha 8y ago…houses are insured for different things than cars are?
- riskneutral 8y agoHome insurance is considerably less expensive than auto insurance today. If auto insurance prices fell to the level of home insurance, then it does effectively kill the industry as we know it. It’s not a very good comparison anyway, as home insurance covers a variety of perils which are often caused by human error (e.g. fire), as well as natural perils that are not really applicable to auto insurance (e.g. flooding due to plumbing issues, or roof damage due to wind storms).
- smileysteve 8y agohome insurance covers personal liability of the insured and the premises - and the rate of "collisions" is very far from 0.
- joshe 8y agoThis is some confusion about this, most of our insurance premiums go to paying claims. Most insurance companies operate with a slight "underwriting loss" or slight "underwriting profit", but usually quite close to even. The companies then make money by investing the "float". So premiums going down by 90% is an implied 90% reduction of harm from cars. That's both property damage and human injury. Warren Buffett: "...so vigorous indeed that it sometimes causes the P/C industry as a whole to operate at a significant underwriting loss. This loss, in effect, is what the industry pays to hold its float". [1] [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-insurance-float-2017-4 https://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-insurance-flo... (with a nice explanation).
- rubyfan 8y agoGEICO and Berkshire Hathaway are a unique beast in the industry. Their ability to gainfully employee capital is somewhat unmatched. Historically many companies managed to eek out an underwriting profit but distracted driving and bodily injury changed the game for many auto underwriters over the years following the iPhone's debut. Just in the last year or two or so years have some companies returned to modest profitability in this line. If you are not Warren Buffett your need to generate an underwriting profit is more or less essential. Weak returns on low risk investments vehicles which have performed worse in a post crash world make it even harder for insurance companies in general and make underwriting profit even more essential. If you are a multi-line writer at this point you are well aware of the impact that autonomous, vehicle services and mobility services will have on auto. At this point its slightly better than a loss leader for other more profitable lines.
- riskneutral 8y agoThere is no confusion, 90% reduction in premiums directly leads to a 90% reduction in “float.”
- codyb 8y agoWouldn't the insurance companies keep any float they'd received up until the sharp decline in coverage costs?
- olivermarks 8y agoYet another 'might' article....
- jaimex2 8y agoThey will also kill government revenue raising from speed cameras. A billion dollar figure here in Australia.
- eximius 8y agoNot unless there is legislation preventing cars from being told to drive above the limit. I set my adaptive cruise control over the limit so I catch up to the car in front of me, for example.
- delinka 8y agoYour adaptive cruise doesn't "know" what the speed limit is. Self-driving cars have this information, whether from a database or by reading a sign. It remains to be seen how much enforcement the software will perform.
- randyrand 8y agoCars will still crash. We have 2 options - build the cost of insurance into the price of the car, or let owners buy it themselves. IMO Id rather have the ability to buy my own insurance and have various choices of coverage. Nothing needs to change.
- r00fus 8y agoI'd pay a small premium if it's built into the a single ongoing cost of a car. I know I'm not alone - Insurance industry is one of the least trusted. This may be bi-modal - many many folks would agree with you, but enough might agree with me for someone enter the market - potentially disrupting it.
- smogcutter 8y agoHow am I liable for an accident caused by my self driving car, though?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> How am I liable for an accident caused by my self driving car, though? Because you failed to maintain the vehicle in a safely operable condition. Now, if s manufacturers defect contributed to that failure, the manufacturer may also be liable, but that doesn't mean you aren't liable, and the manufacturer is going to claim and try to prove that that isn't the case.
- rwmj 8y agoIn practice that sounds impossible. Am I supposed to audit the code? I probably don't even get to see the code, and even if I did we don't have any even theoretical way to audit the neural network parts.
- bsagdiyev 8y agoBut you can audit tires, physical damage to sensors, cameras, etc so if an accident were to be caused by failure to brake caused by rain and bald tires, that is entirely your fault. ABS will only take you so far.
- lr4444lr 8y agoThe self-driving car manufacturers and downstream vendors themselves will need tremendous coverage when any accident can suddenly pin at least partial liability on them. That cost in turn will be passed down to consumers.
- maerF0x0 8y agoWith premiums plummeting then laws about liability can rise. For example in California by law you only need $30k coverage. In Alberta it's $200k (most have $1 Million). This is really surprising given in California an ambulance can cost that much, whereas healthcare is nearly free in alberta ($250 ambulance iirc).
- gambiting 8y ago30k mandatory coverage? Is that a joke? EU has nearly free healthcare everywhere so car insurance almost never pays for any immediate treatment in accidents, and the legally required minimum is 5 million euro in 3rd party liability. On my own insurance I pay about £450 a year and my 3rd party liability is 20 million euro(and I didn't even select that as an option, it's just what it is).
- vegardx 8y agoJust speculating, but could it be since there's very limited ability to file for personal bankruptcy in most European countries?
- gambiting 8y agoEven if that was the case(I don't believe it is - there's nothing difficult about filling for bankrupcy it's just that the consequences can be rather severe - you can't run a company or get any kind of loan for years and years afterwards), why would car insurance companies go above and beyond what is required by them? My insurance is with Aviva, and I know as a fact that they are only required by law to offer 5 million euro coverage. Yet my policy clearly states 20 million euro 3rd party coverage. Why? I didn't ask for it at any point, and it still seems far beyond anything that I could ever cause in an accident. And it's certainly not like they advertise this fact anywhere, so it couldn't even be a marketing tactic(hey come with us, we offer more coverage than any other company!). It's just their bog standard policy as far as I can tell.
- sek 8y agoThe best insurer is the one with the most data and ability to analyse it. Nobody can beat the self driving car operator, they need that information anyhow to improve the capabilities of the car. Interest alignment is also with the self driving company, they have any incentive to improve safety of the car. They are simply liable so they act as an insurer and just add that to the cost of the self driving module. For the buyer this should remove most need of insurance. Even if there is some "manual mode" the obvious provider would also be the self driving operator. They could track driving behaviour and adjust the rates, or offer some limitations for accident prevention. So the insurance itself is still there, but it will be less important and shift to the self driving operators. Even if you own a car, you would pay some fee for the self driving module for updates and liability in one package. I worked for insurance companies. Car insurance is a huge business, but not a very profitable or even sold at a loss. It is often used to get new customers to offer them other more lucrative products. That going away is still a huge shift and those companies are very old and slow.
- gumby 8y agoThis article has it backwards: payouts will drop, so premiums will drop (less drastically if they can get away with it). In fact once autonomous vehicles really get working it will likely become very difficult to get permission to drive a vehicle instead of having it drive itself. The insurance companies were instrumental in the development of things like fire codes, bank safes and the like; they hate paying out claims because their business model is to hang onto the premiums and invest them.
- cascom 8y agoYup - driving your car will go the way of the diving board in a pool (not illegal, but outrageously expensive to insure)
- offWorld 8y ago...and no one shed a tear.