6 ms·
I believe that in fact the numbers do exist as physical objects exist. Just in their own universe. When we reason about numbers, we're embedding a representati
by kazinator 8y ago
I believe that in fact the numbers do exist as physical objects exist. Just in their own universe.
When we reason about numbers, we're embedding a representation of a universe of numbers into our universe.
What we call "physical existence" could is also probably just be "math all the way down". Just not in such a way that the number two per se can be an entity for us to behold.
- stcredzero 8y agoI believe that in fact the numbers do exist as physical objects exist. Just in their own universe. How is it any different than believing that unicorns exist as physical objects, just in their own universe? What we call "physical existence" could...just be "math all the way down". Or, math is also a number of simplified alternate views of reality of varying degrees of "applicability." (Where "applicability" has to do with predictive power over reality.)
- kazinator 8y ago> How is it any different than believing that unicorns exist as physical objects, just in their own universe? We have very well-developed representations of the number universe that we can embed into our own universe. These things are governed by precise axioms. By contrast, we don't have such well-developed "unicorn universe". (For starters, what is the definition of "unicorn"? If it's just a horse with a horn, then such a thing is plausible with genetic engineering in our universe.) As we endow the unicorn with additional properties, then it becomes less and less clear that there exists a universe where such a thing can exists other than as an imaginary being. If the concept of a unicorn could be axiomatized, then it could constitute a universe. > Or, math is also a number of simplified alternate views of reality. Well, that's the math that we do; not the math that we (possibly) are.
- stcredzero 8y agoWe have very well-developed representations of the number universe that we can embed into our own universe. These things are governed by precise axioms. By contrast, we don't have such well-developed "unicorn universe". Indeed. The current better known attempts at a "unicorn universe" have problems with power scaling and the square-cube law. https://www.reddit.com/r/mylittlepony/comments/mrs81/according_to_my_dodgy_backofthecoaster_maths/ https://www.reddit.com/r/mylittlepony/comments/mrs81/accordi... Do you have a good definition of what constitutes a "well-developed" universe?
- AgentME 8y ago>Do you have a good definition of what constitutes a "well-developed" universe? An easy definition would be one where everyone agrees on the exact mechanics and sequence of states. The fibonacci sequence is well-developed: it has an exact definition that every competent simulator can simulate the same way. If I say my favorite number is the 1000th item in the sequence (starting with 0, 1, 1 as items #1, #2, #3), then everyone can calculate the 1000th item the same way. If we all try to talk about what happens in the "unicorn universe", everyone has their own different ideas about that. There's no unambiguous rules for how the unicorn universe is calculated. Everyone has a different "unicorn universe" in their heads, and each of those universes operates on our own mind's whims rather than any rules we can describe to each other.
- stcredzero 8y agoIf we all try to talk about what happens in the "unicorn universe", everyone has their own different ideas about that. Homo sapiens has this issue with this universe. Even if you subset that group to just scientists, there are still differences of opinion.
- AgentME 8y agoReality itself is well-defined in that it acts consistently with itself. We as humans don't have a well-defined embedding of this universe into itself. We would need to know the complete underlying rules of physics for that.
- FabHK 8y ago> How is it any different than believing that unicorns exist as physical objects, just in their own universe? Good question, but I think there might be a difference. Suppose, in a galaxy far, far away, there are aliens. They probably don't have the concept of unicorns. However, they probably have discovered numbers, pi, Pythagoras theorem, e^(i pi) + 1 = 0, etc. So, does the fact that something is discovered (rather than invented), and can be discovered many times independently in identical fashion, confer it some sort of elevated ontological status?
- kazinator 8y agoI would sadly have to say no. Because in some completely different universe unlike ours, the aliens have no concept of, say, "hemoglobin" because there isn't matter like ours: no atoms, no iron, no carbon. Unlike numbers, hemoglobin and unicorns contain a kind of arbitrary complexity. Yet one is definitely real. Some real entities are far removed from elementary math (even though they may ultimately rest upon it, many levels down). The question is: are unicorns bunk, or are they like hemoglobin.
- FabHK 8y agoI'm not claiming that if something exists (haemoglobin), we must have a notion of it and true statements about it in every universe. Rather: if we have a notion of something and statements about it in every universe, then it must exist. However, come to think of it, that's bonkers. Still, it's remarkable that mathematics allows us to make reproducible true statements about fictional objects.
- stcredzero 8y agoHowever, they probably have discovered numbers, pi, Pythagoras theorem, e^(i pi) + 1 = 0, etc. We can only be confident of that if they're in this universe. Also, this is only a conjecture. It's just something some of us imagine would be true. You can't elevate such an idea to the level of empirical data. So, does the fact that something is discovered (rather than invented), and can be discovered many times independently in identical fashion, confer it some sort of elevated ontological status? Unicorns. Kirin. Narwhals. Rhinos. So you have two independent origins in culture for such a creature, plus two appearances of something similar in nature. Does that confer it some sort of elevated ontological status?
- Retra 8y agoThat other "universe" is just patterns embedded in our brains. That's all you need. You could likewise argue that sounds exist in a different universe, but are only "embedded" into the air using pressure waves, but why would you ever think you needed a different universe of sounds when you've already got pressure waves in air? I mean... what's "not enough" about that for you? >What we call "physical existence" could is also probably just be "math all the way down". This is a needless diversion. Mathematics is the study of structure. Physical reality has structure, and very well could "be structure" in some equivalent sense, but to say it is math is just abject poetic nonsense. This change of language would literally make no significant difference to anybody about anything. You may as well be declaring the world to be flat and asking everybody else to go and change all our language to make it true.
- incompatible 8y agoYeah, mathematical objects like numbers are concepts in our brains, or imaginary objects. Numbers in particular are imaginary objects used for counting. You can set up an isomorphism between these numbers and real-world objects, e.g., to count them.
- roywiggins 8y agoThe strange thing about mathematics, as opposed to other noncorporeal ideas, is that it is nearly uniquely suited to being transmitted between brains. My idea of the number "three" and your idea the number "three" are probably very similar. This sort sensation that they have an independent existence leads people to the Platonic notion of a mathematical "realm" or "universe". (personally I think mathematics exists in our brains, but also and crucially in the interactions between our brains, since a proof is never accepted until it is reviewed and so on. A proof that's just in my brain is no proof at all, even if it happens to be correct)
- Retra 8y agoYou could say that about most language we use: it's meant for transmitting thoughts between human brains. Why would it be bad at it? Besides, there are plenty of mathematical concepts which are hard to understand. I don't see any uniqueness to math here.
- jerf 8y agoYou may be interested in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothes...