2 ms·
I guess I see the point being made, but it was all a bit long on rhetoric and analogy, and short on concrete examples.
by ineedasername 8y ago
I guess I see the point being made, but it was all a bit long on rhetoric and analogy, and short on concrete examples.
- Animats 8y agoYes. This is the same argument that audio nuts make for analog recording. It's known to be bogus. (Yes, 16-bit CD audio has resolution problems for soft passages, and early filters for the sampling rate were not too good. We're past that.) One of the few concrete examples of a complex analog computer system still used in recent decades was the F-16 flight control system. It's a four channel fly by wire stabilization and control system, all analog. It was, at the time, the most advanced flight control system, and it's still well thought of. That's from the 1970s, and modernized F-16s use a digital replacement. For several decades, full authority digital flight control systems were disfavored in aerospace because there were no analysis techniques to be sure they were bug free. There are ways to analyze an analog computer system to be sure that the test case set is sufficient, and that behavior will be smooth continuous between the test case points. Eventually that problem was solved for digital flight control systems, and now everybody goes digital.
- Junk_Collector 8y agoAnalog computers still crop up in all sorts of places these days but have become very niche and are typically a small part of an otherwise larger system. It's rare to see a general purpose analog computer outside of a very small number of research labs and FPAAs exist but are expensive novelties. As digital processors continue to get better and we develop better ways to work with them, there just isn't the need for the cost and effort required to make analog computers. Some common places where you might see one is in audio driver amplifiers where it is common to implement a bit of trans-linear logic at the output stage to reduce distortion. Same in some high quality power supplies. Sometimes very high performance sensor systems will have an analog pre-processor to perform some calculation on the incoming signal before handing it off to the digitizers and DSP. Think multi-microphone arrays.