4 ms·
Exactly. The logic of this argument seems to be: luck is involved in being successful, therefore personal effort plays no role at all. It makes no sense. I l
by refurb 8y ago
Exactly. The logic of this argument seems to be: luck is involved in being successful, therefore personal effort plays no role at all. It makes no sense.
I like your measure relative to what you were born into. Didn’t get enough to eat when you were a child and are now a millionaire. Self-made!
Born into a millionaire family and turned that into a billion? Self-made!
I’m personally thankful the tall poppy syndrome isn’t that common in the US. I’d hate an environment where success is looked down up. No, being rich isn’t everything, but if that’s what you want, I’m happy you found it.
- EliRivers 8y agoIf I was born poor, and then someone gives me a bunch of money, by this argument I am self-made.
- lwhalen 8y agoYeah, that's what we call "a job". Make yourself useful to a rich enough person or group of people, they'll "give you a bunch of money" and call it a "salary".
- EliRivers 8y agoYeah, that's what we call "passive aggressive childishness". Or perhaps I need to really spell it out to you. Under this definition, if I am born poor and someone gives me, free and for gratis, with no obligation or return on my part, a big pile of money, I am self-made. Like that nice man who let George Clooney sleep on his couch for a while, and Clooney came back twenty years later and gave him a million dollars. Self-made. Or those people who win the lottery. Self-made. Or those people who inherit a fortune from a relative who didn't give them spit while they were alive. Self-made. Or a lady born in 1950 in South Korea, in a village without electricity, whose grandson now maintains her in an eye-wateringly expensive flat in Seoul because he rode the rise of South Korea to riches. She's self-made too.
- refurb 8y agoIf someone gave you $1M and a decade later you had $1.5M, no you're not self made. If someone gave you $1M and a decade later you had $100M, yes, you are self made.