3 ms·
> But how do we know that the scout's belief is right? I feel like the assumption in the article is that neither is right, but that the scout is searching for
by dahart 8y ago
> But how do we know that the scout's belief is right?
I feel like the assumption in the article is that neither is right, but that the scout is searching for right, and the solider is defending right.
> Seems like the author has already come to the conclusion that its always going to be right. Doesn't that just bring us back to the mindset of the soldier?
I don't think so. The mindset distinction isn't between right and wrong, both types prefer to be right. The distinction is whether you're a motivated defender of an idea in spite of the evidence, or whether you're searching for truth and willing to change your position.
If you think about this in just pure statistical probabilities, who's more likely to be right at any given time, the person who is certain they're right, or the person who has changed their mind to favor the evidence?
It feels like this might even be related to the Monty Hall problem to me; once you have some evidence that something's wrong, there's a distinct statistical advantage to changing your mind, even when you don't know and you're choosing randomly.
- jumpman500 8y agoI like this. I think you have a better interpretation than my initial one. If it is sort of probability based than it can't be right or wrong, just sort of incomplete until we observe the consequences of the action. More often than not the scout will probably be right, and I can concede that. But that doesn't imply that the soldier will always be wrong either.
- dahart 8y ago> But that doesn't imply that the soldier will always be wrong either. Completely agree! I maybe implied too strongly that soldiers claim to be right against contrary evidence, which isn't what Julia said. Not only are soldiers often right, people often defend their stance and stop looking for the right answer precisely because they are right and know it. The risk is just that sometimes that decision is made prematurely. Personally, I probably revert to soldier when I think I'm being a scout more often than I want to admit.