6 ms·
Why you think you’re right, even when you’re wrong (2017)
- andyjohnson0 8y agoJulia Galef did a talk last year for the Long Now Foundation on the soldier/scout mindsets [1]. It's about 90 minutes including questions, and I found it interesting end engaging. [1] http://longnow.org/seminars/02018/sep/12/soldiers-and-scouts-why-our-minds-werent-built-truth-and-how-we-can-change/ http://longnow.org/seminars/02018/sep/12/soldiers-and-scouts...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xutopia 8y agoScouting as described in this article is exactly what we need to foster in today's false news world. I am doing all I can to drive this point home with my children.
- king_panic 8y agoSimple explanation for why we think we're right even when we're wrong: we perceive what we believe. Not the other way around. Even when we're dead wrong. In psych they call this confirmation bias. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias Scott Adams wrote a fantastic book on the subject, in the context of Trump's election to the Presidency. https://www.amazon.com/Win-Bigly-Persuasion-World-Matter/dp/0735219710 https://www.amazon.com/Win-Bigly-Persuasion-World-Matter/dp/...
- jumpman500 8y agoBut how do we know that the scout's belief is right? Seems like the author has already come to the conclusion that its always going to be right. Doesn't that just bring us back to the mindset of the soldier? Maybe we just have to accept that part of the experiment of living in a democratic and free society is allowing people to create their own values, and accepting that people are going to get it wrong. Their values are going to conflict with ours, and that's good because we need to be sure our values are actually worth holding.
- dahart 8y ago> But how do we know that the scout's belief is right? I feel like the assumption in the article is that neither is right, but that the scout is searching for right, and the solider is defending right. > Seems like the author has already come to the conclusion that its always going to be right. Doesn't that just bring us back to the mindset of the soldier? I don't think so. The mindset distinction isn't between right and wrong, both types prefer to be right. The distinction is whether you're a motivated defender of an idea in spite of the evidence, or whether you're searching for truth and willing to change your position. If you think about this in just pure statistical probabilities, who's more likely to be right at any given time, the person who is certain they're right, or the person who has changed their mind to favor the evidence? It feels like this might even be related to the Monty Hall problem to me; once you have some evidence that something's wrong, there's a distinct statistical advantage to changing your mind, even when you don't know and you're choosing randomly.
- jumpman500 8y agoI like this. I think you have a better interpretation than my initial one. If it is sort of probability based than it can't be right or wrong, just sort of incomplete until we observe the consequences of the action. More often than not the scout will probably be right, and I can concede that. But that doesn't imply that the soldier will always be wrong either.
- dahart 8y ago> But that doesn't imply that the soldier will always be wrong either. Completely agree! I maybe implied too strongly that soldiers claim to be right against contrary evidence, which isn't what Julia said. Not only are soldiers often right, people often defend their stance and stop looking for the right answer precisely because they are right and know it. The risk is just that sometimes that decision is made prematurely. Personally, I probably revert to soldier when I think I'm being a scout more often than I want to admit.
- undecisive 8y ago
- Isamu 8y agoThis is very interesting. >Julia Galef is a writer and co-founder of the Center for Applied Rationality, a nonprofit organization devoted to helping people improve their reasoning and decision-making, particularly with the aim of addressing global problems. She is also the host of the Rationally Speaking podcast. http://www.rationality.org/ http://www.rationality.org/
- kgwxd 8y ago"Julia Galef is a writer and co-founder of the Center for Applied Rationality" So the author has definitely heard the term "confirmation bias". Why make up a new term for it?
- dahart 8y agoI can easily see a distinction between a known bias, or "motivation", and an unknown bias. What's wrong with allowing language to make that distinction?
- theoh 8y agoShe probably does know about cognitive bias, but you can't seriously be suggesting that her bio establishes that with certainty. People who write and set up organizations are a very mixed bunch. Galef is not exactly a high-powered scientist or philosopher. "Motivated reasoning" has it's own Wikipedia page: it's fine to talk about it as something distinct from cognitive bias. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motivated_reasoning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motivated_reasoning
- king_panic 8y ago"Motivated reasoning" is the product of confirmation bias. That's where the distinction ends.
- theoh 8y agoNo. If anything confirmation bias is a consequence of one particular case of motivated reasoning. I think you will need to make a much stronger case if you want to convince anyone that this distinction is not useful (and that, therefore, the dismissive comment I initially replied to was justified.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- king_panic 8y ago
- a_c 8y agoNot sure where I read, maybe Nonviolent Communication or somewhere else, paraphrased - "Being right feels the same as being wrong". Think about hundreds of years ago where people debate about whether the earth is flat, either side truly believed they were right, even though one clearly wasn't
- jmcqk6 8y ago> "Being right feels the same as being wrong". From the book "Being Wrong" by Kathryn Schulz. I highly recommend it!
- tialaramex 8y agoNo. They didn't. People who actually thought about this tended to pretty quickly figure out that the only shape that works is the globe, a big ball. They estimated how big it was. The ancient Greek estimates are pretty good. The result was disheartening if your employer was an emperor because the globe was much bigger than their empire. Still, you could point out that maybe most of it is just ocean. Most people didn't think about it at all. Seriously insisting that you believe the Earth is flat, generally as part of some larger grand conspiracy theory, is a modern phenomenon.
- ggggtez 8y ago>hundreds of years ago This debate is (somehow) still raging, in case you didn't know.
- tombert 8y agoI have tried to employ the strategy of "I'm probably wrong all the time". It's not perfect, and occasionally I'll get defensive about something that I find out is wrong later (I was staunchly against unit tests for example), but having a mentality that your mind is fairly fallible is a good way to avoid yelling at people, at least for me. I do wish it were more politically acceptable for politicians to adopt this mindset. Without espousing a side of "Democrat" vs "Republican", it feels like the world views admitting that you are incorrect as a sign of weakness, or "flip-flopping",
- LiquidSky 8y agoUnfortunately that's just the reality of how people think. The person who is making confident declarations is going to come across as stronger and more inspiring than the person who is being careful and thoughtful, no matter who is actually correct. It's not really a liberal or conservative thing, either. Someone making a passionate progressive speech is going to appeal to those inclined that way more than someone making a careful, nuanced progressive argument. Politicians know this and so will always hedge towards appearing decisive and "strong".
- jtbayly 8y agoPerhaps you ought to assume you are wrong that you were wrong about unit tests. :)
- tombert 8y agoI just try and not hold any viewpoint with any dogmatism now. I'll admit that maybe people will come back and realize that unit tests were stupid, but this time at least I'll know that I was neither a staunch defender or detractor.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoThe final truth is usually, "it depends…"
- avinium 8y ago
- mcgwiz 8y ago"What do you most yearn for — to defend your own beliefs or to see the world as clearly as you possibly can?" Before you answer the latter, ask yourself when was the last time you admitted to someone you were wrong about something significant to you both? Can you do so more often?
- sandwall 8y ago'To fight against confirmation bias, is to fight the hardest battle and never stop fighting' Biases are built in, it takes effort to be rational.