5 ms·
It is a bit more nuanced. As pointed out by the appeal record (http://www.seattleschools.org/area/board/10-11agendas/111710agenda/appealrecord.pdf http://www.s
by kenjackson 16y ago
It is a bit more nuanced. As pointed out by the appeal record (http://www.seattleschools.org/area/board/10-11agendas/111710agenda/appealrecord.pdf http://www.seattleschools.org/area/board/10-11agendas/111710...) there were three required non-fiction books for the 10th grade list: BNW, Othello, and Lord of the Flies. Apparently all three make reference to native or indigenous people as "savages".
And then apparently in one lecture they promoted an inaccurate view as to why we have reservations.
It's kind of like the Huck Finn example. If you read that book and it says the n-word -- that's one thing. But if the other two required books also say it, then it begins to get a little odd. I think people would reasonably begin to ask, "you couldn't find one book that didn't say nigger/savage in it?"
Although her attacks on the text itself were misplaced and uncalled for.
- anigbrowl 16y agoNo, it's worse - the whole episode is a glaring case of illteracy run wild. The original complaint and supporting documentation describes BNW and the other cited works as 'non-fiction.' The complaint about the word 'savage' appears predicated on the assumption that it has never been applied to anyone other than Native Americans. The members of the reconsideration panel seem oblivious to why the objections are so misplaced. After being notified (via a form letter) of the decision to take it off the curriculum and her right to appeal said decision - which she does, requesting it should be removed from the required reading list for the whole school district and not just that which her daughter attends. Despite attempts by the faculty and principal to explain the meaning of the book she apparently still believes it's a work of non-fiction. Cluelessness all round...at best. At worst, abuse of process as a poor justification for a shakedown.
- corin_ 16y agonon-fiction?
- MarkSweep 16y agoThe person writing the complaint letters repeatedly referred to the books as "non-fiction". See page 10 and 12 in the parent comment's PDF link.
- corin_ 16y agoBut you weren't quoting it, you were calling them non-fiction yourself... and by any definition possible they are fiction.
- masklinn 16y agoI didn't read it that way at all. I read his comment as saying the list has a list of 3 books labelled as mandatory and non-fiction (and an unspecified number of books which maybe be any of optional and fiction), and then giving that list. He didn't call the books anything at any point.
- kenjackson 16y agoAt the point I was writing them I was just paraphrasing the text. When I wrote non-fiction my mind converted it to "fiction". I'd call it a primed typo. She does use the term non-fiction multiple times, although I don't think anyone could believe they are.
- rbanffy 16y agoPerhaps we should concentrate on why people are so offended when characters in a book say "nigger" or "savage".
- kenjackson 16y agoReally? Is that something that you really need to concentrate on? And honestly, are people that offended? What percentage of ppl in the US care? What percentage of Blacks and NI care about Huck Finn and BNW respectively? Maybe the saddest thing is that people like Rbanffy will use this to fuel a conspiracy that there is some nationwide outrage around these books, when none exists. I guarantee you there is a thousand times more outrage in the US over the existence of the Koran.
- rbanffy 16y agoWhen did I imply there is a nationwide outrage? I only wonder why that mother was so annoyed by the term "savage" and why others are annoyed by "nigger" in fiction books written generations ago. "People like Rbanffy"... I am not sure what you intend to imply by that.
- jbooth 16y ago45 short years ago, use of the n-word was typically followed up by turning a firehose or a pack of dogs on people who just wanted to be treated like human beings -- this was happening, in modern America, while your parents were in grade school or high school (presumably). You might not have been aware of that, given that you seem to think that everyone should just get over it and not be offended by things that don't offend you.
- rbanffy 16y agoThe question is not what happened, but what can we do so it never happens again. By the time the events you mention happened, my family was still coping with having to leave its ancestral home after WWII and having to move to Brazil as refugees. We can hold grudges for many generations if we want, or we can learn from the past and move on.
- kenjackson 16y agoHere's a story from a local blog that goes into greater detail. http://saveseattleschools.blogspot.com/2010/11/brave-new-world-indeed.html http://saveseattleschools.blogspot.com/2010/11/brave-new-wor...
- protomyth 16y agoThat blog post (and the comments at the end) sure give a really different impression of the event than the article.
- kenjackson 16y agoOur news media is a narrative driven media. They find their narrative and build the story around that. Details, subtleties, and complexities get shoved under the rug. For example, look at the health care debate. Headline news for over a year. Here's a quiz, ask 10 people to name 3 concrete aspects of Health Care reform. I tried an not one person game me 3. A few gave me two. The mode was zero concrete aspects. The narrative never was the bill itself. What everyone did know was that Obama and the Dems won and the Republicans lost, and it it costs a lot of money. For a year of coverage, this was the only narrative. Win/Lose + costs money. A lot of people wonder if the decline of newspapers means that things like city council meetings don't get coverage. I've discovered that you often get better coverage from reading a couple of blogs -- and there almost certainly will be better targeted blogs than you get from your major city paper.