3 ms·
Maybe there's some misunderstanding. The top-level comment was about the introduction of uncertainty transitioning (early) from the SAR model to a provincial m
by arcticbull 8y ago
Maybe there's some misunderstanding.
The top-level comment was about the introduction of uncertainty transitioning (early) from the SAR model to a provincial model. I took your reply as saying "nothing's going to change for investors because Beijing isn't stupid" -- I agree, Beijing is far from stupid. I'm actually agreeing with you in another comment where I point out 'uncertainty around the handover' has been something investors have lived with for a generation, and this won't change any time soon.
I would also say in spite of the fact there's an international referee looking over this, they're totally unable to do anything, so for better or worse, it is effectively an internal matter now.
IMO, however, a better model of Hong Kong is that it remains a colony as it has (almost) always been, what changed in 1997 is whose colony.
My devils advocate comment was to say that as the UK is totally powerless (and much of the rest of the international community with it) and Beijing's more forceful stance on the SARs of late, that they may just cut off the SAR model entirely. Who's going to stop them? As you say, it's an internal matter.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoSounds like an accurate summary to me. Whatever China chooses to do with Hong Kong, the UK and others have little influence. As you say the Foreign Office can send a memo. Chris Patten may have been deeply disappointed at London hadn't objected more, but that would have realistically changed nothing. So practically speaking it effectively is internal. Whatever that document might say. The clearest mistake, to my mind, of the whole handover was Thatcher being unwilling to grant passports for all.
- jacobush 8y agoYes, granting passport would have changed a LOT of things not only between the UK, China and HK, but in the world I think.