3 ms·
Do people honestly think this is disproportionate for investigating a home invasion? I think the concern is not Google sharing this data once they have it. T
by michaelt 8y ago
Do people honestly think this is disproportionate
for investigating a home invasion?
I think the concern is not Google sharing this data once they have it. The concern is Google having it, in the first place (in personally identifiable form).
There's a lot of unclarity about which free and paid Google services and products are and aren't tracked. Who knows if their DNS resolver or their wifi-visibility-to-phone-location service or google-maps-used-without-logging-in would have come up in such a search warrant?
- bagacrap 8y agoHold on, this is great justification for Google having this data (in addition to the real reason, which is to provide better location-based services). Due to the anonymization process, no one's privacy is unduly infringed upon, and investigators have a tool for catching criminals. Do you not see that last bit as a societal win?
- bepvte 8y agoWe know, because its outlined in their privacy policy that they store dns logs for 24 hours, and store the location data of devices which allow the location history feature, and provide data to governments who send a proper search warrant with reasonable cause.
- pubutil 8y agoMy problem isn’t so much that Google is storing location data if people have agreed to allow it. The semantics of agreeing to enable location history are arguable, but by default Google’s location history feature is opt-out. I’d prefer it be not be that way, but that’s a debate for another time. What I do have a problem with is what this line from the article suggests: >An Associated Press investigation last year revealed that even with these settings disabled, Google continued to collect and store users' location data. Maybe I’m missing something from the TOS, but it seems to me that the opt-out process doesn’t do what it describes; so what is it for?
- ilovetux 8y ago> The concern is Google having it, in the first place This. I think it's the only responsible thing for the police to do. Since they know the data probably exists they have to look, but does this data need to exist? What we need is some limitations on what is collected and how long it is stored.