Your loop example is more akin to the "anti-recent" pattern: the most recently accessed item will not be accessed again sooner than any of the four other items.

Your loop example is more akin to the "anti-recent" pattern: the most recently accessed item will not be accessed again sooner than any of the four other items. Contiguous patterns may well be anti-recent, whether an access is "recent" or not should be considered in relation to the size of the cache.