My recollection is that the studies showing that code reviews have high defect yield are for extremely strict methods. Everyone in a room, prescribed roles for

My recollection is that the studies showing that code reviews have high defect yield are for extremely strict methods. Everyone in a room, prescribed roles for each person, line by line, checklists, forms, the whole nine yards. Comments on pull requests are not on the same level and those findings shouldn't be hastily generalised.