3 ms·
I don’t even want the ability to refer someone into my company. That’s very risky and puts pressure on me to be right, when I might be wrong. I have referred fr
by dahart 8y ago
I don’t even want the ability to refer someone into my company. That’s very risky and puts pressure on me to be right, when I might be wrong. I have referred friends who’ve been rejected, and I’m glad because that’s better than hiring my friend and having them not fit in. Then it’s my fault.
I’ve interviewed and referred many people and made a lot of hiring decisions, I would rather have everyone agree, I don’t think the ability for a single person to refer someone past the interview process is a good idea at all.
None of the risks listed even compare to the risk of hiring someone who isn’t actually very good or doesn’t get along with the team.... and despite thorough interviews that still happens all the time. If the candidate is worth referring, then the interviews will not likely be a problem. Things do go wrong occasionally, but not very often.
Edit: I also meant to add that I think referrals are already weighed very heavily in interviews in my experience. Sometimes even too much. Interviews are already easier for candidates when someone who’s respected makes the referral, so to some degree the proposal here already reflects reality.
- hinkley 8y agoI don’t refer friends, I refer former coworkers that I would like to work with again. Problem is I don’t have the same diversity in my referral pool as I’d like to see at work. Last couple of places have been pretty homogenous and I’m less keen on referring people I last worked with ten years ago.
- dahart 8y agoOf course. My coworkers are also my friends. By “friend” I mean people I know that I’ve worked with before and that I like and would vouch for because they’re good, as opposed to people I’ve worked with that I don’t like, or social acquaintances. I’m with you on diversity too, these days I prefer interviewing people I don’t know and people with very different backgrounds than mine.
- gav 8y agoThe solution to the fear of being at fault is to ask the person making the referral a question like: [ ] I have first-hand experience of the candidate's technical skills [ ] I have first-hand experience of the candidate's character [ ] Neither apply I've worked at several places with versions of this; they want referrals in the pipeline to avoid having to pay recruiters, there's no skipping interviews.
- dahart 8y agoRecruiters are expensive, but good ones are worth it. I like having a mix of recruits and referrals. I could have answered that in the affirmative, but I suspect it wouldn’t help, for several reasons: If I get someone hired who doesn’t work out, it would still be my fault, and everyone would know it, even if I did double-vouch for them, or disclaim it, either way. When someone doesn’t fit in, in my experience, it’s usually due to people’s agendas and desires, and not usually because their technical skills or character is questionable. One friend I referred recently had moved and just needed a job. He was interested in checking out the place I worked. At the time I had switched from embedded development to web, and he was considering a similar move. He bombed the interviews even though I know he’s both technically competent and of high character. He wasn’t as interested in web as he made it sound, he just didn’t want to hurt his chances. I was worried he’d be upset with me, but he called me after he got rejected and apologized, then told me he was glad it didn’t work out because it didn’t seem like his cup of tea. I’m glad I had the safety net of the interviews, because it would have been bad if he’d been hired. I would totally still refer the same guy again, because I know he’s a good hire.