3 ms·
I actually feel that criticism should be empathetic rather than dispassionate... it should be worded to show that you understand the person is a competent profe
by cortesoft 8y ago
I actually feel that criticism should be empathetic rather than dispassionate... it should be worded to show that you understand the person is a competent professional who was working in good faith, but might have missed something or made a mistake.
This is why I try to word reviews as questions, not statements of facts:
"Is this supposed to be reversed? I think it might not do what you want it to"
"Having a bit of trouble following this logic.. is there a way to make it more clear to future readers?"
"I might be missing something, but I don't see how this code can be reached?"
Don't give the review in such a way that implies you know everything and the other person was wrong. It should be a dialog, and be based on the assumption that we don't yet know the right answer and are working together to figure it out.