7 ms·
How? My grandfather wrote a book in the 1940s that’s been out of print since the mid 50s. Every entity associated with the book is dead, including the publishe
by Spooky23 8y ago
How?
My grandfather wrote a book in the 1940s that’s been out of print since the mid 50s. Every entity associated with the book is dead, including the publisher, which merged into another in the late 50s and is probably an inactive imprint of some successor company. Grandpa died in 1985, and a cousin or I is likely the heir to his rights.
I have a copy of the book, which I bought via Alibris from a bookstore in Wales 15 years ago. If you needed the book for research, you’d probably get it via inter-library loan from a university or a big city library. Whomever the publisher is, they don’t have it and aren’t selling it. In no scenario does anyone get paid for transacting, other than a reseller or the post office.
- greglindahl 8y agoThat's a classic "orphan copyright" situation.
- ghaff 8y agoRight. And orphan works legislation has tended to be opposed by individual creators or at least the organizations that purport to represent them. The (not totally unreasonable) theory is that individuals or their estates--let's leave aside the fact that copyright terms are almost certainly too long--may well inadvertently not keep on top of what's needed to keep works non-orphaned. But "Disney" (or whoever) will most certainly be ready to pounce on anything they can acquire for free for whatever technical reason.
- mimixco 8y agoRight... And since Google Books probably has a scan, who cares if you download the PDF? This problem is impeding real research without helping anyone.
- dwyerm 8y agoStay with me for a second; I'm going to go wildly afield... does intellectual property need an Adverse Possession law, too? [1] Your grandfather had a book, the rights of which should have been presumably passed down to you. My grandfather had a patented mining claim that has been passed down to me. Where the ownership of your grandfather's book is questionable, for me the physical corners of the property are questionable. A number of them are defined by things like a "4 foot spruce post" or a "12 inch diameter tree trunk" that haven't survived the ravages of time. But it is important that I patrol my property at least every couple of years because of Adverse Possession. If someone else were to use my property continuously and I don't say anything against it, one day their trespassing suddenly and magically would become ownership. For a land-owner, it is a scary idea that someone can steal my property from me, as has actually happened. [2] But I can acknowledge that it makes some sense. It comes from the idea that land is meant to be used, and if you aren't using it, maybe the person who is using it should get the rights. If nobody can stand up for an intellectual property claim, perhaps some kind of adverse possession is in order. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession [2] http://articles.latimes.com/2007/dec/03/nation/na-land3 http://articles.latimes.com/2007/dec/03/nation/na-land3
- function_seven 8y agoI like the analogy between real estate and copyright. I think a simpler* solution would be to return to limited terms on copyright (say, 14 years), and require periodic renewal by the rights-holder to extend that term. As part of the renewal process, you'd either need to demonstrate active use of the copyright, or pay a fee (or both?). * Simpler from a process point of view. I understand it's probably not simple politically.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoExponentially increasing fee, set in a way that past two-three such renewals, even the biggest and richest corporations would think twice before paying up.
- gwern 8y agoWe actually do have a sort of 'adverse possession' in US copyright law, for libraries: the "Last 20" clause, which IA has recently begun exploiting for distributing still-copyrighted books (https://blog.archive.org/2017/10/10/books-from-1923-to-1941-now-liberated/ https://blog.archive.org/2017/10/10/books-from-1923-to-1941-...).
- mikez0r 8y agoCounter-argument: Adverse possession is justified by the scarcity of real property. Which does not apply to IP. - Real property (i.e. land) is a scarce and limited resource. If a party is making productive use of the land, they should hold title. (There is only so much arable land. If someone raises crops, let them.) - Intellectual property (particularly copyright) is not a scarce or limited resource. (Create your own copyrightable work if you wish to own the rights.)
- mikez0r 8y agoOf course, adverse possession presumes that land ought to be made "useful." (Haven't thought yet about how these critiques of real property theory map to IP.) Much of real property theory arose from the assumption that the government should recognize and encourage the "highest and best use" of real property. Traditionally, the highest and best use of land is the use that can most profit from the land's resources; often mining, grazing, farming, logging. This is problematic. - This view justifies colonization, and taking land from original inhabitants who don't use the land to extract resource value. - This view does not recognize preservation of an ecosystem as a valuable use. - This view does not account for externalities from use of the land's resources.