5 ms·
And who's fault is this? It's not hard to make a good app. I could implement XMPP messaging in the Facebook app given a few hours and given a few days for a cou
by drivebyacct2 16y ago
And who's fault is this? It's not hard to make a good app. I could implement XMPP messaging in the Facebook app given a few hours and given a few days for a couple other missing bits, I could get the feature parity down to nothing between the Android and iOS Facebook app. Why this hasn't happened, despite the explosive growth of Android, despite the fact that Zuckerberg is now an Android-user, etc, I don't know...
but the unintelligent comments here and on Engadget are frustrating. Blame the app developers, not the platform. That's just silly.
- rchowe 16y agoIt's not hard to make an app, but it's very hard to make a great app. Most devs obsess about design the same way designers do and most designers can't code very well.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoRight, I didn't mean to imply otherwise. But when Facebook decides to give the iOS app more attention than the Android app... well, I can't really blame that on the platform. Really? Someone drive by downvoting both posts without any discussion? Come on, man up and have a discussion. I'm sorry that I don't accept "Android sucks lol" as a reason for why the Facebook app is so much better on iOS devices. It's the same darned reason that the design studio projects my class is working on this year are all based on iOS devices for limited use-cases that would be more easily deployed, serviced and cheaper with an Android solution.
- rchowe 16y agoiOS is more polished and has more room for actual design. Android is a drastic improvement on what was running on smartphones before, but the built-in UI doesn't have the same fit and finish as the iPhone UI. For example, look at the iPhone status bar (the bar at the top of the screen that shows the battery, signal, and time). Now look at the default android status bar. The iPhone one just looks better because all of the icons are the same height. The android icons' goofy roundedness only almost fits with the other standard UI elements. Designers/Developers on a polished platform will make more polished apps. Designers/Developers on a rougher platform will tend to make rougher apps. Note that there are exceptions, but this represents the overall trend.
- jrockway 16y agoiOS is more polished and has more room for actual design. And this affects integration of an XMPP library how? Designers/Developers on a rougher platform will tend to make rougher apps. So is this why you can't maximize any apps on OS X?
- dkasper 16y agoBefore you say "I could do this in a day these guys suck" I suggest you reread this article: http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2009/07/code-its-trivial.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2009/07/code-its-trivial.ht... The devil is always in the details, and you probably could get the first 90% done in a couple days and then you'd have to do the other 90%, make sure the design is perfect, and test it thoroughly. It's a lot of work, and I'm sure the team (which is probably smaller than you think) is working crazy hard on keeping the app up to date with all the changes at Facebook. I'm pretty sure they're going to be working hard to add the "seamless messaging" feature they announced to the app, not just writing a simple xmpp client.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoI've done application development for both. The comments here mock Android in the typical fashion that I'm used to. The delicious part is that there is no one responding to anyone of my commentary in asking, is there something magical about iOS that makes the apps just more amazing. (The Android app has been out for 3 years and probably at least a year and a half before their seamless messaging was even being considered. It's no excuse for why the iOS FB app got messaging and Android didn't. I called out XMPP... you know... because that's the protocol that FB Chat uses. Additionally, the entire point of the seamless messaging is that it doesn't matter which protocol the communication goes over, it's all aggregated to the same place.) Does the Facebook's app presence on an iOS device magically give it photo album support and chat support? No, that's silly. So, all of you that continue to downvote me and aren't bothering to respond to my actual contention, I'll ask again. Why are we making fun of Android as a platform rather than indicting the developers that don't bake in the same features. I've seen the code for a simple XMPP client in Android, and I know that it would not be hard to implement in the Facebook app. Yet it isn't. And Android gets blamed for it. The comments here are unintelligent, but then again they usually are on anything iOS/Android related. Finally, I never ever said they suck. I'm sure their priorities are elsewhere, I just don't understand why.
- drivebyacct2 16y agoAbsolutely none of the replies have addressed the fact that there is such a huge feature and quality disparity between iOS apps and Android apps that are clearly the result of resources alloted to each app. And then commenters here, indict the platform because of it. This is illogical and I don't understand it. And people keep down voting me without any discussion. It's the pathetic fanboyism I expect elsewhere.