4 ms·
To play dictator's advocate, that's the story of how civilization overcame stealing and homicide. More seriously, all problems are rooted in human psychology b
by whatshisface 8y ago
To play dictator's advocate, that's the story of how civilization overcame stealing and homicide.
More seriously, all problems are rooted in human psychology because technology is now good enough for us to live in a utopia if we could only manage to stop turning it against ourselves. So, really that pattern is just proposing that the government take something over, you get the first step for free.
- sverige 8y agoThe problem is that "the government" is made up of people who have the same problems rooted in human psychology, and those people are a subset of the general population self-selected for the specific problem of wanting to tell others what to do. I'm more inclined to agree with the aphorism that government is the problem, not the solution.
- ben_w 8y agoAn understandable position, however given that why governments appear to be the cause of problems appears to be the same as why my self-described “revolutionary Communist” friend thinks that businesses are the problem, I’m inclined to instead blame inheritance — both plutocratic and aristocratic — from preventing true meritocracy. http://wondermark.com/c1135/ http://wondermark.com/c1135/ Well, that and Goodhart’s Law.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoHumans are not angels. We need government precisely because humans are not angels. We need someone to restrain human tendencies toward violence, toward fraud, and so on. But as you point out, the government isn't composed of angels, either. So we need the government to restrain the people, but we also need to restrain the government.
- travisoneill1 8y agoA ban (as in your examples), or more generally regulation, is not at all the same thing as the government taking over an industry altogether.