4 ms·
The Path Amazon Rejected
- skilled 8y agoBig Corp: We don't need to pay taxes, our employees do it on our behalf.
- yalogin 8y agoAmazon screwed up when they made choosing a place into a reality contest. That came off as egotistical and people took notice. They brought the attention on to themselves. I think they finally realized that walking out of it and letting it die down is the best way going forward.
- trikonasana 8y agoThat seems to be the popular opinion (that this is Amazon's fault) but I disagree. Amazon coming to LIC would have been a net benefit for everyone. 25k jobs that pay a minimum wage of $15/hour...who would reject that? Sure they get a $3b tax break, but they would have paid far more than that in state taxes over the long term. The people on the city council did not represent the the best interest of the citizens, instead trying to spin this as a stand against corporate greed. It's too bad they couldn't work this out. I think this will hurt NYC in the long run.
- perfmode 8y agoHow much did amazon pay in federal and state taxes in 2017 or 2018?
- greenyoda 8y agoEven if Amazon paid no corporate income tax at all, their 25,000 employees would still be paying many millions of dollars a year in state and local income taxes, real estate taxes and sales taxes. And both Amazon and its employees would be buying lots of goods and services from local businesses, generating even more taxable economic activity. Some of these employees might even eventually leave Amazon and found new startups in NYC.
- pathseeker 8y agoMassive amounts. Whoops, I think you forgot to qualify your statement with "corporate income tax".
- nicoburns 8y ago> Amazon coming to LIC would have been a net benefit for everyone. Only in NYC, if you average over the whole country, far more poeple benefit if amazon don't get massive unfair tax breaks.
- bogomipz 8y ago>"The people on the city council did not represent the the best interest of the citizens, instead trying to spin this as a stand against corporate greed." It sounds as that you haven't spent any amount of time in Long Island City then. LIC is is home to the NYCHA housing project called The Queensbridge Houses. It has the distinction of being the country’s largest public housing project[1]. It comprises 26 buildings in various states of decay and 60% of 7K residents live on food stamps. I would say Corey Johnson et al were very much looking out for them. This is the same NYCHA that was sued by the federal government last year and ordered to invest $1 billion in repairs to the dilapidated housing stock and submit to a federal monitor.[2]. LIC's Queensbridge Houses have been very much a poster child for authority's dereliction. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queensbridge_Houses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Queensbridge_Houses [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/31/nyregion/nycha-federal-monitor-repairs.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/31/nyregion/nycha-federal-mo...
- dvt 8y agoI don't buy de Blasio's outrage. If he was truly worried about Amazon being a "bad neighbor," why did he have a carte blanche policy until the very moment they backed off? In fact, it took regular citizens asking the hard questions for Amazon to back off in the first place. Aren't we electing mayors to fight these fights for us?
- blihp 8y agoIt's not outrage, it's spin. He represents one of the two parties that was prepared to engage in a deal that ordinary people get very angry about. (i.e. massive corporate tax breaks) So if the media plays along with the spin, he will succeed in shifting a lot of the outrage away from his administration and on to Amazon.
- bilbo0s 8y agoWell, in fairness, the outrage wouldn't be on his administration in any case. One thing he's conveniently not mentioning is that he was opposed to giving Amazon any tax breaks or other concessions from the start. The state politicians overruled him. Although his position, I suppose, is that Amazon should move to NYC, without any concessions. Which is not altogether off the wall. That's how it should work for ALL companies and all places. Corporate welfare is out of hand in this country. It's just a little idealistic on his part, that's just not how things work in reality. He's gonna get overruled by the higher ups every time on that one.
- crumpets 8y ago>Corporate welfare is out of hand in this country. That's certainly one view. Another is that these are just breaks on excessive taxes by one government to compete with other governments that have sane corporate taxes in the first place. I don't understand how tax reductions are considered welfare. It's not money the government has already being passed out to Amazon. The government would have still made money in this scenario, just less.
- 8y ago
- kevmo 8y agoThis is just a face-saving op-ed by a guy who wants to run for President. The fact that they only gave him an hour's notice shows just how gullible he was and how little respect Amazon had for him in the first place. All of those things he counseled them to do - hire people from the public housing projects, meet with labor organizers, etc - should have been concessions extracted before he signed onto the deal.
- ndespres 8y ago> All of those things he counseled them to do - hire people from the public housing projects, meet with labor organizers, etc - should have been concessions extracted before he signed onto the deal. Exactly my thoughts. Though Amazon should have done this in the first place instead of doing that awful HQ2 search spectacle. Another thing that jumps out when reading this editorial from the mayor is how strange it is to see him acknowledge Amazons behavior with the min wage tax increase in Seattle that they threw a tantrum about, and yet still he invited them to come to NYC with the tax breaks on a silver platter.
- kevmo 8y agoWhat really blows my mind about this is that we are talking about New York City. NYC is absolutely stuffed with America's best talent. Amazon needs NYC so much more than NYC needs Amazon. The entire HQ2 shakedown was always just Amazon seeing how much they could fleece NYC. It's ludicrous New Yorkers are having to do the bargaining they elected a mayor to do for them.
- dangban 8y agode Blasio tweeted this after Amazon cancelled: https://twitter.com/NYCMayor/status/1096110674613358593 https://twitter.com/NYCMayor/status/1096110674613358593 "working with the community" is code for "bribe" among the community organizer types.
- sempron64 8y agoSounds like he's projecting a bit. Pot and kettle...
- dtrailin 8y agoThat's an incredibly uncharitable insinuation. Do you think community organizers do it for the money? There are a lot of reasons people choose to advocate but regardless of weather you think they're right they generally do it because they actually believe in something. It's unlikely fighting Amazon is a very profitable venture.
- lamarpye 8y agoIt's unprofitable if you drive them out of town. If you can position yourself as a community liaison rep, it is a sweet gig.
- pathseeker 8y agoThey certainly do it for the power (the majority of them). Very few people put themselves in that position without an eye for moving into politics to continue their power growth. Remember, the vast majority of people do not do things long term for altruistic reasons.
- ww520 8y agoSounds about right.
- nrb 8y agoI don't read it like that personally. I mean, judging by some reporting[1] it sounds like the final meetings involved a framework for unionization efforts which to Amazon was probably unpalatable enough to pull out entirely just based on that. I guess if you consider "working with the community" to equal "greasing the local union bosses" then maybe. But it's just more logical to just imagine that Amazon doesn't want to exist a blueprint for other unionization efforts nationwide. 1: https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/15/amazon-held-11th-hour-meeting-before-pulling-the-plug-on-nyc-hq2-rpts.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/15/amazon-held-11th-hour-meetin...
- sheeshkebab 8y agoAmazon wanted public money to setup their operations - well they got it together with all the rest that comes with it. If they ever take federal money (and going down 0 tax rate is that path), they’ll need to pray they won’t be nationalized.
- my_usernam3 8y agoI'm skeptical of the article. I most want to see a more descriptive summary of "the agreement we struck with Amazon back in November". Is it public?
- joemaller1 8y ago> Just days before, I had counseled a senior Amazon executive... Can pretty much stop there. I think Amazon saw a mayor and governor who thought they traded tax breaks for a say in how Amazon runs its business. This was a huge loss for the city. LIC will be toxic to big business for years. And now the mayor is passing the blame to the very corporations who would come in and create jobs.
- perfmode 8y agoNYC doesn’t need their jobs.
- lamarpye 8y agoRight. The State Government is running a huge surplus: https://www.wsj.com/articles/tax-shortfalls-widen-new-yorks-revenue-gap-11550329288?mod=hp_listb_pos1 https://www.wsj.com/articles/tax-shortfalls-widen-new-yorks-...
- bogomipz 8y ago>"LIC will be toxic to big business for years" You mean like Citibank, JetBlue, Fresh Direct and Steve Madden who all moved to Long Island City years ago and continue to flourish? Or like Ralph Lauren who just signed a lease for 19K square foot of space and Cornel University's building of their Techion campus? Yeah right. I'm amazed on the number of people who appear be not only unfamiliar with Long Island City as a neighborhood but also of NYC and it current economic well-being in technology jobs. And yet these same folks feel compelled to make comments about what a "huge loss" this is.
- pathseeker 8y agoThose companies pay garbage.
- bogomipz 8y agoYour comment as is as uniformed as it is absurd. Many of those are fortune 500/publicly traded companies. That not withstanding, the comment was that that the business environment would somehow now toxic in LIC which has exactly zero to do with salary ranges.
- aristophenes 8y agoBasically, a plea for everybody else to make it more difficult to do business in their local community, so NYC can be more competitive. I'm sure there is a tragedy of the commons somewhere in the "pitting cities against one another" as he mentioned. But perhaps it isn't ideal to think that a large corporation needs to come to your city and fix your problems either, and that it's not fair that they don't want to. With a corporation the size of Amazon, US cities aren't just competing against each other. The US is a whole is competing against other countries. And these companies are competing against other global companies. Of course they are going to want the lowest hassle, highest efficiency, and largest margins possible. Surely helping the poor and encouraging business don't need to be diametrically opposed. One might think the two go hand in hand.
- Vehemental 8y agoOne way to get Amazon to contribute to fixing a cities problem would be to tax them but they aren't paying any taxes.
- crumpets 8y agoThat's a problem with the government. Amazon isn't evading taxes. It's using standard government legislated tax deductions and rebates: http://www.newser.com/story/271410/amazon-banked-11b-in-profit-year-and-paid-what-in-taxes.html http://www.newser.com/story/271410/amazon-banked-11b-in-prof...
- unreal37 8y agoMayor of New York: You gotta be tough to make it in New York. Businesses with lots of money: Let's go where it's easier
- perfmode 8y agoLet them go. New York doesn’t need their business. New York needs to heal its social fabric and see to the needs of the communities. This is often at odds with economic growth and corporate interest.
- geuszb 8y agoNot all businesses with a lot of money... For example, the financial industry is not going to leave New York anytime soon, as New York is their talent hub.
- tracer4201 8y agoI don't understand the outrage towards Amazon. 1. No one forced any of these states/cities to join this bidding contest. They willingly participated. "How dare Amazon put cities against one another in a bidding war?!" Yeah, I put five dealers against one another in a bidding war to get my business the last time I shopped for a car. Amazon can do the same thing. 2. "Jeff Bezos doesn't need our tax breaks!" I bet he doesn't. I don't think Jeff Bezos personally helped elect all the leaders who offered all these tax breaks. At the end of the day, Amazon will create jobs. Will it gentrify these cities? Yes, absolutely. So would Google, Apple, or Facebook moving into a new area. "But those other companies didn't ask for tax breaks." They literally hold hundreds of billions in wealth overseas. I'm not arguing in favor of tax breaks for Amazon. I am saying, however, Amazon didn't stage a coup against these mayors and governors and threaten to hurt them if Amazon didn't get tax breaks. NYC officials (at least some) openly invited Amazon. Good on Amazon for walking out. Private companies don't owe you anything. The system is broken. Neither party has done anything to fix it. You have a company taking advantage of the perfectly legal rules that the system set up. OH GAWD better grab pitchforks. Yet, all the same lying Congressional leaders get re-elected election after re-election. This de Blasio character openly invited Amazon. Now that they've backed out, he's angry that Amazon had cities bid against each other and that it was so wrong? Are you kidding me? de Blasio is a prime example of what's wrong with American politics.
- bilbo0s 8y ago>Private companies don't owe you anything... Money quote. These are businesses, not charities. So they have to make business decisions. Amazon was right to walk away. (And yes, I realize that the same business reality will oblige Amazon to put several more thousand jobs in NYC in any case. But guess what? I'd bet any money they won't put as many as they would have. They will put several more thousand in DC instead.) Before anyone gets mad at Amazon for behaving in this manner, yell at your political leaders for making these offers in the first place.
- baddox 8y ago> Yeah, I put five dealers against one another in a bidding war to get my business the last time I shopped for a car. Amazon can do the same thing. Surely the reason most upset people are upset is that these deals with governments tend to involve tax breaks, and taxpayers have every right to concern themselves with tax policy. I doubt many of those people would also be upset with your car negotiations.
- org3432 8y agoI think SNL had a good point, Amazon isn't the worst company in NY, the Trump Organization is also there remember.
- zavi 8y agoBeing a sore loser is always a poor strategy. Reflect on mistakes made and opportunities lost and move on.
- DLA 8y agoVirginia thanks NY for those extra jobs. The issue here is NY’s leaders are idiots and don’t understand the fundamentals of economics. Deferred or reduced taxes on Amazon (investment) in exchange for many thousands of good paying jobs (return) and all the down stream economic benefits as those employees pay taxes on good salaries, buy houses, buy cars, and participate in a plethora of other economic activities in the local environment (further returns). Keep electing clowns that want to keep raising taxes, adding regulation, and are unfriendly to business and you get a free market result - companies leave or don’t come to NY in favor of other more business friendly locations. Brooklyn loses a set of very good jobs due to political blundering yet people people want to blame “evil” Amazon. Sorry, that’s not how this works. Good for Amazon.
- jmpman 8y agoHow much was AOC responsible for this?
- parrellel 8y agoMinor bandwagonning at the end by all sane accounts, but she's a convenient face for it, I guess.
- jedberg 8y agoWhy would Amazon try to make things right in NYC, when they can just go somewhere else that welcomes them with open arms and no complaints? NYC didn't offer them anything of particularly great value that they couldn't get elsewhere. I wish they were being better about helping the communities they are moving into, but I can see why they would just leave.
- bogomipz 8y ago>"NYC didn't offer them anything of particularly great value that they couldn't get elsewhere." You mean like access to a very large and very skilled labor pool? A 24 hour transit system, 3 major airports? 1 million square feet of available office like they were going to take in Citicorp tower that has a train stop at the bottom of the building? Sure.
- jedberg 8y agoAmazon doesn’t need a large local labor pool. They get far more applicants than they need and plenty of people willing to move to work there. There are lots of cities with empty office space. And in most cities parking isn’t a problem so the transit isn’t necessary. You gotta think like Amazon — most of those things weren’t huge benefits to them. They were benefits to their future employees but only in that city. The main things they are looking for are tax breaks and rapid development without a lot of red tape. NYC was proving that rapid development was out of the picture and so was the lack of red tape.
- bogomipz 8y ago>"Amazon doesn’t need a large local labor pool. They get far more applicants than they need and plenty of people willing to move to work there." Nonsense. It's far more efficient to be able to tap a local labor pool. Google, FB, et al set up shop in NYC for this ver And there are always people who don't want or can not relocate. Or who simply do not want to live in New York City. >"And in most cities parking isn’t a problem so the transit isn’t necessary" Please name just one top tier city where parking isn't a problem and mass transit isn't necessary.
- siculars 8y agoEating that popcorn watching Democrats out progressive each other. Long after AOC and her socialist friends have exited the scene, NYC will be paying for this. Amazon will simply take their jobs somewhere else. Somewhere else will get 25k six figure jobs and all that comes with them. Personally, I hope they go to Philly to singlehandedly reinvigorate that city at the expense of NY. If not Philly, I can assure you Dallas will welcome them with open arms.
- narendranag 8y agoAs a non-American, I have a question about two things that stand out for me (and do correct me if I'm wrong): the first is that Amazon pays no federal taxes. The second is that corporations seem to expect locals to pay for things that they can then make money off — Amazon's installation in this instance but also American football stadiums stand out as an egregious example. What responsibility (if any) do American companies have towards the communities/societies they exist in (beyond delivering value to shareholders -- wherever they may be)?