2 ms·
> the electric field moves with the electron Sort of. Describing it as an "electric field" assumes the electron is not moving; if it's moving, at the very leas
by pdonis 8y ago
> the electric field moves with the electron
Sort of. Describing it as an "electric field" assumes the electron is not moving; if it's moving, at the very least there will be a magnetic field as well as an electric field. Also, as I said, when we take quantum effects into account we need to quantize the electromagnetic field as well as the electron, so the field is no longer just something that "moves with" the electron; it's a separate thing of its own that happens to interact with the electron in a certain way.
> The electron is still a point particle (to the extent of our current laws of physics) and it will only interact with the plate at one point.
Not a point; the damage on the plate will have a finite size. But you're right that the damage on the plate won't look like the wave function as a whole. Also see below.
> In actuality the electron didn't cause the damage to the plate. The electric field did.
If this is true, you can't deduce that the electron is a point particle from the damage at all, since the damage tells you about the field, not about the electron.
> It's not like the electric field is smeared around because the electron is in a superposition of states.
You're mixing up two different things. If the electron hits the plate, it's no longer in a superposition, and neither is the field. If the electron is in a superposition, it's because it hasn't hit the plate yet, so we haven't measured it--and in that case, the field is in a superposition too. So the "smearing" of the electron and the field go together (in the oversimplified model we're using).
> I'd expect gravity to work the same way.
The issue with gravity is that the "field" in the case of gravity is the spacetime metric. All of the reasoning about the electron and the electric field assumed that the spacetime metric was known. But if gravity is quantized, the spacetime metric itself would be in a superposition if its source (say some massive object) were in a superposition. That's a crucial aspect that's unique to gravity.