10 ms·
When Divorce Was Off the Table, English Couples Dissolved Marriages with Beer
- HumanDrivenDev 8y agoIn 2019, it all looks terribly misogynistic. No losing your house, no alimony... maybe they were on to something. Let wives also be able to sell their husbands and bring it back!
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoIf you own a house before marriage, perhaps a prenup would be prudent. Otherwise, it wasn't really your house, it was the family home. Not everywhere has alimony either. If the money-making wife leaves the husband who has raised kids, he's just out of luck.
- fiblye 8y ago>If you own a house before marriage, perhaps a prenup would be prudent. If you're worried about losing a significant sum of your assets as a result of marriage, the only solution is to not get married. Prenuptials are generally considered to be worthless and any decent lawyer will find a way to get them thrown out. According to point 5 here [1], a case could easily be made that the plaintiff wasn't prepared for having to find a house after divorce, their quality of life is significantly worse than the standard they've come to adapt to after marriage, etc. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jefflanders/2013/04/02/five-reasons-your-prenup-might-be-invalid/#2c52d7d719a5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/jefflanders/2013/04/02/five-rea...
- BadassFractal 8y agoAs anecdata, I remember getting the same legal advice as well years ago: prenups get thrown out by the judge all the time, so you might as well not bother having one.
- logicchains 8y agoOr marry someone trustworthy, and make an informal agreement about how to split assets upon divorce. And if you don't trust them to keep that agreement, should you really be marrying them?
- gear54rus 8y agoWill you vet them for a decade before committing for a few decades? if not, how would you know the agreement will be honored after longer time than you know them? Can you be sure of that with anyone?
- logicchains 8y agoI suppose it depends on how much confidence you have in your ability to assess somebody's character.
- black-tea 8y agoIt's not about trust. People change.
- logicchains 8y agoPeople's feelings change, but how much integrity somebody has (whether they keep their word) is a part of their character, and people's character changes less frequently.
- black-tea 8y agoNo, no. People change. Trust me. Every single man who got divorced was sure he found the one. Every single one.
- close04 8y agoEspecially when there’s even a financial incentive to getting out of a relationship you no longer enjoy. Everybody has a price, and seeing your marriage failing and a financial bonus to getting out of it changes opinions and convictions pretty fast. This is especially true in countries that openly favour one of the spouses. For exaple ones where the legal framework doesn’t consider the contribution each spose had to the marriage, and one of them will invariably receive financial aid.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 8y ago>the only solution is to not get married You will pay whether you’re married or not: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common-law_marriage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common-law_marriage
- badpun 8y ago> If you own a house before marriage, perhaps a prenup would be prudent. Otherwise, it wasn't really your house, it was the family home. I don't know how it works in the US, but here in Poland, all your assets from before marriage remain exclusively yours after you marry. They're not subject to split in the case of a divorce.
- seszett 8y agoIt's the same in France, I works have thought it was pretty much universal (well, in the West at least).
- garmaine 8y agoNot in places like California, where many HN commentators are. Everything by default becomes common ownership unless you explicitly take steps to establish otherwise, with only a few exceptions (e.g. certain retirement accounts). It’s a state level thing though, so there isn’t one story for the whole US.
- cesarb 8y agoIn Brazil there are three modes you can choose: the full one in which all assets are common, the partial one in which the assets from before marriage are separate but the assets from after marriage are common, and the separate one in which the assets are kept separate. A quick web search tells me that the default was full for marriages until 1977, and since then the default is partial (https://lucenatorres.jusbrasil.com.br/artigos/450042665/os-diversos-regimes-de-bens-no-brasil https://lucenatorres.jusbrasil.com.br/artigos/450042665/os-d...).
- black-tea 8y agoIf you own anything before getting married, don't get married. In fact you should probably just not get married at all. Can't believe that men think it's a sensible thing to do. I see immediate downvotes. No logical arguments to refute the claim, of course. If I were to say that taking a payday loan is a bad idea that would be OK, I guess. But you can't talk about marriage.
- x220 8y agoIt really is a sign of our times that any situation not completely favoring women above all else is called misogynistic.
- holdenc 8y agoSomewhat off-topic, but here's how it works today: For a long term marriage in which one spouse never worked, that spouse will likely receive spousal maintenance (alimony) calculated based on the last four years of income from the earning spouse. That will be owned in perpetuity regardless of future earning power. And if you can't pay it, expect to be found in contempt of court, and possibly see prison time.
- isostatic 8y agoWhat country? Citation?
- holdenc 8y agoCountry: USA Citation: https://www.nj.com/hunterdon-county-democrat/index.ssf/2012/12/divorcee_sits_in_jail_while_ua.html https://www.nj.com/hunterdon-county-democrat/index.ssf/2012/...
- dragonwriter 8y agoThat story does not support the claim it is offered to support.
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoYup, because what should happen is that the working spouse should leave the non-working spouse penniless and homeless, especially if they have been married 20-40 years. I will, however, add that not everywhere does any sort of alimony - not every state in the US does it, even, and I can only imagine the difference between countries. I originally from Indiana, which only allows such thing in a limited number of cases. There aren't laws that provide for it. If your spouse leaves, you are just out of luck - though you might be entitled to some retirement benefits.
- holdenc 8y agoIn most cases marital assets are split evenly, including future social security payments to the non-working spouse. Permanent alimony creates an extreme burden because it is not sensitive to changes in the primary earner's circumstances.
- ekianjo 8y agoThe article keeps using the word "selling" to make it sound like the women in question had no choice in the matter, but every example they give is of women who already lived/had a relationship with their extra-marital lover. So it was basically just a way to seal an already existing relationship.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- humanrebar 8y agoFTA: > “The practice in England was not really a sale, but rather a sort of customary divorce plus remarriage in which a woman who had committed adultery was divorced by her husband and given to her partner in adultery,” says Matthew H. Sommer, a Department of History Chair at Stanford University and author of Polyandry and Wife-Selling in Qing Dynasty China.
- grondilu 8y agoGood times. Can someone remind me of any good reason to marry a woman nowadays?
- hd4 8y agoNot really, the family courts in most Western nations have made it completely untenable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hopler 8y agoTo raise children, to have regular access to safe and intimate sex, and all the lifestyle, cost saving, and health benefits of cohabitation with someone, in the expanded pool of potential partners that includes women who want marriage. But opting out of family life and ending your gene line is fine, it increases competition for the men who remain.
- quickthrower2 8y agoNone of that requires literal marriage, although that lifestyle is essentially the same as marriage.
- psyclobe 8y ago> to have regular access to safe and intimate sex lol, you've never been married have you
- hexane360 8y agoBecause you love them and want to express that?
- fpalmans 8y agoMarriage is a formal agreement between two parties with respect to the rules through which they will break up.
- nn3 8y ago
- sfopdxnonstop 8y ago"one spouse never worked" Found the misogynist who means "two spouses together worked on lifestyle with one paycheck".
- lxmorj 8y agoWe had a guy come to our warehouse and work for a week. Pretty good worker. We got a wage garnishing letter and he owes like $25k for two kids each (thought they were duplicate docs at first), $8k and $3k. He stopped coming or answering his phone as soon as we got the letters... Now plenty of things could have happened, but my theory is the garnish is high enough that he’s rather bounce around and get one ungarnished week out of as many different places as possible. Even if the math doesn’t work out, he may just be resentful enough to blow off jobs that comply w garnishing.