6 ms·
Hi. I'm the Tech Lead of Google Registry, the team that is launching .dev (not to be confused with the linked Google Domains, which is one of many registrars s
by CydeWeys 8y ago
Hi. I'm the Tech Lead of Google Registry, the team that is launching .dev (not to be confused with the linked Google Domains, which is one of many registrars selling .dev domains to end users).
You'll be glad to know that TLDs can't simply be discontinued like other products might be. ICANN doesn't allow it. The procedures in place preventing a live TLD from shutting down are called EBERO; more details here: https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/ebero-2013-04-02-en https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/ebero-2013-04-02-en
The way it works is that all registries must send daily full backups to a third-party escrow provider, which are then used to restore the TLD under a different operator if the original operator shuts down unexpectedly. This is not some theoretical backup/restore procedure that goes untested; it's been used in the past, e.g. with .wed: https://www.icann.org/news/announcement-2017-12-08-en https://www.icann.org/news/announcement-2017-12-08-en
But this typically only happens when the registry operator goes abruptly bankrupt, and is thus quite rare. Many, many widely used TLDs have been seamlessly sold/transferred across registry operators without you ever realizing it, including .io last year. That would be the "worst" you would expect from TLDs launched by large established players like Google. You actually get a lot more protections with gTLDs than you do with ccTLDs (such as .io), as ccTLDs aren't bound by contract with ICANN and thus aren't forced to do EBERO, or anything else for that matter.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- longcommonname 8y agoWhat prevents Google from charging an absurd rate like some of the other TLD or other practices that effectively change the service?
- CydeWeys 8y agoThe trend across the gTLD industry has been one of decreasing prices, not increasing prices. I'm not sure what you're referring to?
- cabraca 8y agoi guess he is talking about the premium domains: > During both the Early Access Program and General Availability, there is a $12/year cost for .dev domains. Annual fees may vary for Premium domains.
- bduerst 8y ago"Premium" domains are resold domains. The prices are typically dictated by the person holding them.
- CydeWeys 8y agoPremium prices are set at the registry level, and for Google's TLDs, are charged annually. The EAP fee is a one time only up-front cost. Domains being sold by resellers are something different entirely, but yeah, some registrars that participate in reseller networks may lump those in as "premium" as well, which is confusing. Those prices tend to be one-time acquisition costs.
- 18pfsmt 8y agoBecause this is your area of expertise, can I ask you why more registrars are not selling 10 or 20 year domain ownership? Who wants a domain for just a year (if you agree with the premise behind individuals owning domains in the first place)? If I could buy a domain for 50 years, I'd do it.
- CydeWeys 8y agoMost TLDs allow registration lengths up to 10 years. And registrars will happily sell you registration for 10 years. Buy the domain, then immediately renew it for 9 years. I suspect the reason they don't offer a choice of registration years in the initial checkout flow is to reduce purchasing friction -- they don't want you to have to make another choice and then potentially back out of the sale. It's the same reason e-commerce sites will ask you for as little information as they can get away with when checking out your cart; for digital sales many retailers just do zip code instead of full address since they're not shipping anything. As for longer registration periods than that, I suspect it's the same reason you can't, e.g., call up your cable company and try to pre-pay 50 years of service. They have no idea what things will be like that far down the road, and they don't want to have such longstanding obligations weighing on them. It comes down to business decisions, not technical issues; technically speaking the spec allows for up to a 99 year registration period, though I'm not aware of any TLDs that support that. https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5731#section-2.5 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc5731#section-2.5
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- benologist 8y agoYou talk about the protections ICANN gives your customers in case Google goes bankrupt, but what are the protections or recourse your registry or Google Domains created for your customers to ensure recoverable domains and unimpeded uptime if their Google account is banned?
- ldiracdelta 8y agoIf I register a domain, can google boot me off it at a later year if they don't like my politics? Or do I own the domain with the continuing option to re-register it or transfer to another domain registrar? Does google ultimately own the domains and simply lease them to me with no guaranteed option to continue?
- OkGoDoIt 8y agoAlong those lines, if Google decides I’m a bot or nefarious developer as seems to mistakenly happen on occasion judging from recent hacker news posts, will I then lose my domain name? Or at least access to it? At this point tying any major asset solely to a Google account feels risky.
- jjeaff 8y agoBut don't worry, if a mistake happens, I'm sure you can just call Google's customer service and get it straightened out. Ha!
- chipperyman573 8y agoPaid google products, like google domains, have a 24-hour helpline https://domains.google.com/contactus https://domains.google.com/contactus I've heard that if you call during the day you get someone who's actually competent, not just some T1 support person.
- peterhadlaw 8y agoDoesn't matter the level of support, the CEO of Cloudflare was involved and still ended up bringing politics into infrastructure.
- slenk 8y agoWho is a good/trustworthy registrar then?
- ilovecaching 8y agoHi, just wanted to say how absolutely horrid this entire idea is. Domain name squatting and auctioning is already bad enough, and you're telling me we should give one of the richest companies in the world thousands of dollars for a domain name for development. This is completely counter to the spirit of the internet, and spits in the face of open source and passionate hobby developers who don't have silicon valley stock vesting every quarter. Instead of trying to get these domain names into the hands of real developers at a reasonable price, you're going to sell them to the highest bidders, squatters looking for new investments, and corporations. Really not at all impressed by this, and it only serves as a stark reminder of the failed state of TLDs.
- jpatokal 8y agoI don't understand the bile here, nor the alternative. Today there are no .dev domains, so anything is an improvement: today you can't use them, tomorrow you can choose to if you think it makes sense. Re: price, say the .dev registrar decides to offer domains for a hobby-dev-friendly $1 flat fee, first come first served. Wouldn't that just immediately lead to a resale market where predatory squatters register all the domains and extract the market price from anybody who wants one?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- prepend 8y agoI think it’s not cool to offer “early bird” registration for thousands of dollars. So Google is endorsing that rich developers should get the best domain names? How are they reserving for themself? I think it would be cooler to have programming challenges or something neat. But a cash grab just seems kind of, lame I guess. I wouldn’t say I have bile, but I went from “this might be cool” reading the headline to “this is really stupid.”
- Klathmon 8y agoBut if you don't think the dutch auction style is a good one, what would your alternative be? Because the problem of resellers buying up TONS of domain names is a real one, and thus far a dutch auction style seems to be one good way to combat that (since buying 10000 names and selling 10% of them for an overall profit is a LOT more risky when getting them first means shelling out a LOT more money). A challenge or something would probably drive costs up across the board, and it would still exclude those who want to use the domains that might not be able to complete the challenge (IMO a worse situation), and other methods of "verification" would either be gameable or would exclude many devs. I don't know of any more "fair" way of allowing people to buy domains. Why should a hobbyist be able to buy "paypal.dev" when potentially thousands of devs could use that domain at paypal, and similarly "klathmon.dev" would be awesome to have for me, and it's pretty unlikely that someone will buy that out from under me with this scheme. Not to mention that the timeline here is literally half a month. After Feb 28th, there is no additional charge. So we are talking about 2 weeks of waiting.
- shard972 8y ago> You'll be glad to know that TLDs can't simply be discontinued like other products might be. ICANN doesn't allow it Except if your website was the daily stormer.
- CydeWeys 8y agoDaily Stormer never had a TLD. (And no, ICANN never will delegate .nazi)
- longhorn_alum 8y ago> Hi. I'm the Tech Lead of Google Registry, the team that is launching .dev /remindme! 2 years
- mobiuscog 8y agoYet here I am about to lose my .eu domain, because of Brexit. I'm paid up for 10 years, but the EU can just change the rules, and I lose my domain.