4 ms·
No creditor would give a loan to someone who doesn't have a chance of paying it back. There are kids going to school for music therapy that are taking $100K in
by exabrial 8y ago
No creditor would give a loan to someone who doesn't have a chance of paying it back. There are kids going to school for music therapy that are taking $100K in debt. It's time to end government subsidized loans, at least in the current form. The private market does a great job of evaluating risk, the only thing that needs to be done is ensure there is ample competition so it self-regulates.
- maxkwallace 8y agoIn principle I agree, but in practice, it seems like private lenders are empirically doing a bad job evaluating risk. Rates for private loans are so high they can only be explained by a high default rate, even among "low-risk" demographics. These rates are very high even for students that we'd view as a low credit risk (e.g. studying CS and not music therapy). I think this shows the private market is doing a poor job evaluating risk. That said, it's probably still a good thing long-term to end government subsidized loans. But that doesn't mean the private market is healthy. I'm not an expert on this area, and I don't know why there aren't "smart" lenders that do a better job arbitraging this. It could be possible that it's inherently difficult to predict whether someone will default or not. As other people have pointed out, the real problem is the incentive structure for colleges and the increase in administrative staff (and thus tuition) who are enriching themselves at the expense of everyone else.
- nroets 8y agoIt's called adverse selection: A lot talented students happen to have one or more wealthy family member (s) who will either lend or donate the money to them. So commercial lenders receive a disproportionate number of applications from students who will have a difficult time finding a well paid job.
- dorchadas 8y ago> In principle I agree, but in practice, it seems like private lenders are empirically doing a bad job evaluating risk. Rates for private loans are so high they can only be explained by a high default rate, even among "low-risk" demographics. These rates are very high even for students that we'd view as a low credit risk (e.g. studying CS and not music therapy). I think this shows the private market is doing a poor job evaluating risk. Or that they know the risk, but also know people have to borrow so see a chance to profit more from it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- skizm 8y agoStudent loans don't go away in bankruptcy, even private ones. There is no risk even if you loan a poor student $150k to go to art school since you have the rest of their life to garnish wages from them.
- cameldrv 8y agoI think that the difficulty is future adverse selection. Four years after loan is made, we know whether or not the student graduated and got a good job. There is now a student loan refi market, and the risk of someone who now has a degree and a job is much lower. Almost everyone who graduates and finds a job will refi. The loan therefore has to be priced for college dropouts, because those are the only people who won't refi.
- exabrial 8y agoThat's because they're not allowed legally to take those things as risk factors... Which is also hilarious. No creditor world finance a 19 year old male for a $120,000 high horsepower sports car at 6% interest. Yet government regularly does equivalent amount of money.
- zanny 8y ago> The private market does a great job of evaluating risk Like it did in 2007? One in a million voices might have even thought to bring up how spoiled the housing loan market was, but the markets kept singing the tune of growth until hundred year old banks were out of business from loan defaults. That was the government pushing bad loan policy on private banks who lopped them up like candy from a free money fountain until everyone involved got a taste of reality. Private industry easily gets caught in its own deliriums in pursuit of endless profit.
- exabrial 8y agoWhat part of the private market remained to compete after government-sponsored-entity lenders enter the mortgage market during the housing crisis?