5 ms·
When in doubt, racketeer. I've been annoyed by how Google uses Adwords for a while; suppose you're company in a competitive, undifferentiated space. I just sea
by dehrmann 8y ago
When in doubt, racketeer.
I've been annoyed by how Google uses Adwords for a while; suppose you're company in a competitive, undifferentiated space. I just searched for "enterprise rental cars," and the first thing below the search box, an ad, was for getaround.com. The second was an ad for Enterprise, the third was the organic result for Enterprise. Google is effectively telling these companies "You wouldn't want someone to happen to see a competitor first and click them when they search for them, would you? Then pay up." That's a racket.
Same with this. They're inventing the demand for this TLD, then telling developers to pay up if they don't want someone to take their name.
- GordonS 8y agoYou could make the argument with a lot of the (mostly pointless) TLDs that have been released recently, such as .uk, which was a clear money-grab targeting existing .co.uk owners, or .sucks, which feels like an attempt to extort all domain owners.
- dehrmann 8y agoTrue. Also, the new TLDs have gotten out of hand to the point that ICANN launching a new TLD has become noise. Their restraint has been so lacking that I'm expecting punycode emoji TLDs in the next few years. If you thought .sucks was bad, just wait for the poo emoji.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoUgh. I wish I had something more insightful to say, but I read your comment and audibly groaned, because I just know deep down that you're correctly predicting the future.
- zanny 8y agogoogle.com isn't a public place, it also isn't a particularly valuable plot of "land" aside the private goliath built upon it. The fact people go to Google gives them their power to extort business for ranking. But thats because Google remains valuable - people use it because it works, or at least because of inertia that nothing is remotely better yet, and so long as people still value the search companies can do the cost benefit analysis to know if paying the rent is worth it. And its fortunate the only people who really care about search ranking are those trying to make money off it. There are a lot more egregious crimes being committed in the privacy space by Alphabet or by rent seekers across the economy than a business making money as a parasite off other businesses trying to make money.
- dehrmann 8y agoI'm aware of free speech in privately owned "public places" (usually shopping centers) in some jurisdictions (California), but I didn't think that applied to racketeering.
- reaperducer 8y agoThey're inventing the demand for this TLD, then telling developers to pay up if they don't want someone to take their name. For a lot of developers the demand was already there because they had their local virtual hosts on .dev. It wasn’t standard, but it was extremely common. Then one day Google announced that it owns .dev and all the developers had to move their development domains to a different imaginary TLD or .example since Chrome would no longer let them test web sites on their development environments. I am a developer. I will not pay Google or anyone else to use .dev simply because I have learned that Google can not be trusted. What prevents Google from taking .dev back in-house one random day and kicking everyone’s web sites to the curb? Absolutely nothing. Because you don’t own the domain. You only rent it. I keep my development and testing on locally routed .dev and simply don’t use Chrome. Fortunately the people who sign my paychecks only care about Safari. Not everyone has that luxury, but I do, so I will make this minuscule stand that Google will never know or care about because an algorithm cannot know or care.