3 ms·
It's a funny statement when you think about it > the gun misses its target if it's too hot What does 'too hot' mean? Too hot... to do what? How do we define '
by chrisseaton 8y ago
It's a funny statement when you think about it
> the gun misses its target if it's too hot
What does 'too hot' mean? Too hot... to do what? How do we define 'too hot'? Too hot to hit its target? Well that's tautological then isn't it - a rifle that is too hot to hit its target will not hit its target.
Presumably all rifles at some point get too hot to hit their targets, because at some point they're going to simply melt. So all rifles miss their targets when they get too hot. If they're not missing their targets then they're not too hot are they?
I guess what they mean is that the rifle starts to miss its targets at a lower temperature than other rifles, but that's not what they said. It's one of those statements that seems to make sense on first reading but then when you really think about what it says, it doesn't say anything and you could say it about all rifles and be truthful.
- scottlocklin 8y ago> What does 'too hot' mean? "The weapon's capacity to hit targets fell to 30 percent when the surrounding temperature reached 30 degrees Celsius (86 Fahrenheit) or when the weapon became hot through constant use, the report said." https://www.dw.com/en/german-defense-minister-says-no-future-for-g36-rifles-in-bundeswehr/a-18399209 https://www.dw.com/en/german-defense-minister-says-no-future... I mean, I guess they could limit their military operations to temperate days, and not shoot the rifle too much to avoid these kinds of problems.
- chrisseaton 8y agoRight - that's what I suggested it really meant. I was commenting on how the article was phrased not actually about the rifle.
- elcapitan 8y ago> I mean, I guess they could limit their military operations to temperate days, and not shoot the rifle too much to avoid these kinds of problems. It's important to remember that the German army's equipment was originally intended for NATO defense of western Europe, basically to defend a conventional soviet attack in Northern Germany. That's true for the tanks and armored vehicles as well, which also had issues when Germany first took them to places like Afghanistan. Germany participating in operations externally to Germany is only a thing since 1999 (Kosovo).
- scottlocklin 8y agoI don't think it's important to remember that in context of the G36. The gun basically doesn't work if you pop a couple of rounds through it, or if it's hot out. I'm certain it didn't pass any of their mil specs.
- elcapitan 8y agoIt passed all the military specs. That has been settled in court, the manufacturer H&K didn't have to pay any damages.