5 ms·
Woz: Apple Almost Launched A Phone In 2004, Android Will “Win The Race”
- camiller 16y agoHow the hell do you win a race that doesn't end? i.e. - "Aug 30, 2006 ... Why MySpace Won The Social Networking War." There is no "winner" there is only the current leader.
- runjake 16y agoYour words are true, but think of the news as subjective and a snapshot of time. The MySpace headline you mention was referring to MySpace's effective killing of it's competitors (Friendster, Orkut, etc). So for that period of time, they did "win". But yes, the race never ends, it's a journey not a destination, and so on. Some day when my kids have kids, they'll have to explain this antiquity called "Facebook" to glassed-over stares. "That's lame mom, I'll be back, I'm going and check my HolodeckFurrySpace.com page"
- fab13n 16y agoWin the race in terms of volume, most likely: their product is pretty decent, and they aim at comoditizing phones and carriers. But the race that matters is the race in terms of profits, and Apple seems on track to remain the most profitable company, without producing the most common phone: - they have indecent margins; - they have a credible strategy to comoditize carriers (cf. their not-so-secret deal with Gemalto); - they cash in at all stages: on the hardware, on the software, on carrier fees, on the App store; - a significant part of their R&D effort is shared between iOS devices (not only phones) and OSX.
- al_james 16y agoExactly. Google's approach is to lose money on creating the OS and promoting it (give it free to handset manufacturers) but hope to make money off the users that use it. I am sure they can make money from this, however, I am also sure Apple will make more money per user by selling an actual phone to them AND making money from the user.
- bmelton 16y agoI'm guessing that's debatable. I don't know anywhere close to the numbers, but effectively, you're saying that the iPhone (a few hundred dollar purchase up front, plus maybe a few hundred dollars every couple years) is worth more than the lifespan of how much revenue per user those users will be worth using search. The flip side of the gamble is that Google makes money of search and ad revenues even if they don't sell an Android. Sure, the users aren't AS likely to use gmail, or picasa web sharing, or what have you, but they likely make some money off of almost every smart phone user, regardless of whether their phone is an Android, iPhone, Blackberry or Windows Mobile. You might be right, for sure, but I think Google is the long-term winner here.
- raganwald 16y agoWill Apple win by selling phones or will Google win by selling ads? I don't know. Will handset manufacturers win by indenturing themselves to the carriers and with a commodity OS? No.
- al_james 16y agoArh... But apple sells the phone AND the ads (iAd) AND makes a profit from iTunes!
- parfe 16y agoI think the difference is: Apple sells a vertically integrated device where they profit on every level. Google is working to create and grow a mobile market that just didn't exist. I don't think you can compare the two approaches directly. Google is making sure their primary business profit center has a market while Apple is maintaining a top to bottom ecosystem they can control. And they are spreading that control style to desktops.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoApparently Microsoft made more money from Mac Office than Apple did on selling the machines. I can see that being repeated with smartphones. Similarly, I feel much better about switching to Android seeing that all the core uses of my iPhone (Youtube, Gmail, Maps, Calendar, Reader) are provided by Google.
- bcrawl 16y agowins the race as in, how linux wins over microsoft when it comes to servers since hardware is not the issue. Article states that Woz thinks that current non iphone smartphone hardware is already better than iphones. Once android software catches up, which he predicts will soon, it will have "won" the race. The race of which OS has the most installs.
- silvestrov 16y agoThere is something missing in Woz' argumentation: "He likens Android’s success to that of Microsoft’s Windows operating system, along with the flaws and challenges of that model." Problem is: there has for a long time been such an OS on the market: Windows Mobile. It didn't become dominant over time, on the contrary, it is currently in survival mode. Android is more like Linux. Linux didn't become dominant on the Desktop, but Android (i.e. Linux) will fare better on smartphones because smartphones don't rely on an huge existing base of applications and IT-support departments. If Woz' argument was true: Why did RIM (and in Europe, Nokia) and other vertical integrators get the lions share[1] of the smartphone market when the "winner" strategy was already present in the market? They did because the rules are different for the smartphone market than the desktop PC market. [1] http://www.asymco.com/2010/11/03/what-do-you-have-to-believe-for-an-android-dominated-future/ http://www.asymco.com/2010/11/03/what-do-you-have-to-believe...
- akamaka 16y agoI don't believe that was what he was trying to say. I think his point was that Windows was successful by bringing features made popular by MacOS to a wider market and more diverse hardware, just as Android is doing that with the iPhone concept.
- pronoiac 16y agoApple did help release a phone in 2005, the badly-received ROKR - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_ROKR_E1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_ROKR_E1 Collaboration on this started in 2004. It's not a smartphone but I wonder if this is what Woz (mis-)remembers.