4 ms·
> The "modern alternative" is to use a much more specific and much less configurable solution to your problem. The problem is you're replacing one configurable
by kazinator 8y ago
> The "modern alternative" is to use a much more specific and much less configurable solution to your problem.
The problem is you're replacing one configurable, flexible thing, with N different specific solutions involving multiple obscure little utilities. Oops!
How can this blogger not see that this isn't better.
How about a modern alternative to git? Instead of one hydra with so many heads, why not use scp for transferring repositories (not git push), cp -r for saving snapshots of versions (not git commit), diff -urNp for calculating differences (not git diff), patch -p1 < ... for applying deltas, not git rebase ... You know: specific solutions that do one thing, instead of one big, confusing mess.
- tptacek 8y agoBecause it is better. You don't get sound cryptosystems from configurable, flexible things; flexibility is the mortal enemy of cryptographic soundness. That's how "this blogger" "not see" that this isn't better. This isn't some fringe belief among hipster cryptography engineers (among which I'm sure George counts himself). You can read it straight out of _Cryptography Engineering_.
- throwaway415415 8y agostill, from a dev perspective it's not always clear what tool to use for the task. That's a lot of bike shedding for something that shouldn't be a problem in the first place: email or whatever communication system we will use in 20 years needs to have encryption baked in by default. Storing and sharing data safely need to be a first class feature of all OS and browsers.
- tptacek 8y agoWhat's the term of art for bikeshedding something so long that you give up and opt for a solution that is materially worse than all the bikeshedded options? Because that's what you're doing when you debate cryptography and give up and use OpenPGP.
- throwaway415415 8y agoWhere did I say that we need to give up and use PGP?
- yardstick 8y agoWhat if PGP was updated to remove the old cipher suites and only support modern ones like Curve25519 Poly1305 ChaCha20 etc? (At least for newly created keys/sigs/encrypted files) The aspect of PGP I like is the UI integration. At least when using GPG Tools. I can double click on an asymmetric encrypted file and GPG tools will decrypt it. Likewise my mail client can encrypt/decrypt/sign/verify emails automatically with GPGs plugin. If there’s a straightforward equivalent for modern crypto that is easy for users to install and use, let me know because I’d be interested in using it.
- kazinator 8y agoThen it will stop working for the users who have keys and data in those crypto-systems. They will have to use old, unmaintained versions of the software.
- yardstick 8y agoNot necessarily, it could support working with legacy algorithms to decrypt & verify old content. But any new content— any encrypt or sign- would only support modern crypto and associated features (eg newly encrypted files must be armoured / integrity checked, which I believe is optional now). Users would need to upgrade their PGP tool sets, but all their old data would still work. The point I was trying to drive at is all these other tools/suggestions lack a good user experience and ease of integration. GPG Tools offers the best integration for PGP I’ve seen, and is actually half decent. If there’s a modern tool with modern crypto, easy to use, easy to integrate into mail and file management UI (Explorer/Finder/etc) then I’m all ears.
- afiori 8y agobut then also the new systems would not work for them.
- Boulth 8y agoOpenPGP is actually adding stuff. Quite a lot of people use Curve 25519 PGP keys already (e.g. GnuPG and ProtonMail support it).
- kazinator 8y agoWas this reasoning true 25 years ago? If so, why don't we go back to RSA over DES3, with MD5 digests? All that dizzying proliferation of new crypto is wrecking the soundness.
- tptacek 8y agoI don't understand your question. We don't use RSA because it's less secure than curves. We don't use 3DES because it's an insecure cipher with a 64 bit block size. We don't use MD5 because you can generate collisions for it. The point of not using PGP is not being a system that can negotiate us down to things like 64-bit blocks or RSA.