5 ms·
No web of trust? I would say that’s exactly the point. For tons of applications, you don’t need web of trust at all. Using PGP when you don’t want the web of tr
by klodolph 8y ago
No web of trust? I would say that’s exactly the point. For tons of applications, you don’t need web of trust at all. Using PGP when you don’t want the web of trust features is an utter pain in the ass.
I want to be able to encrypt/sign and have web of trust be a different issue.
- taeric 8y agoI feel like this is asking past the point. Without a web of trust, how are you securely signing? You can go with somewhat centralized trust, but that only gets you do far. Or, rather, that forces everyone to deal with that centralized source. Much like the web of trust.
- resoluteteeth 8y agoIf you own a domain and have a webserver running ssl you can distribute your public key in a secure manner. What situations are you encountering in 2019 where you really need a distributed web of trust?
- jakeogh 8y agoIt's almost like not needing to roll your own key distribution mechanism is a nice feature.
- zeveb 8y ago> If you own a domain and have a webserver running ssl you can distribute your public key in a secure manner. That means that I'd be trusting GUANG DONG CERTIFICATE AUTHORITY and every other CA not to issue a fraudulent certificate against my domain. I don't think that's very secure.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoUse a domain that requires certificate transparency and you're basically set.
- jamieweb 8y agoUse a CAA policy in your DNS to lock down the CAs that can issue for your domain, and then monitor for issued certificates with the certificate transparency logs. In modern browsers, certificates are not trusted if they're not CT-logged, so it's impossible for a fraudulent one to exist without you knowing about it (unless it was issued before these requirements were put in place in ~April 2018, but once all of those have expired, it'll be a pretty solid system).
- bmn__ 8y agoThat still does not help against the GP's problem. The most practical – yet totally ridiculous – solution in 2019 is still: for each end user, for each browser, to delete all pre-trusted CAs, and reenable them one-by-one trust-on-first-use. In a few days to weeks, the user ends up with around six active CAs that are actually in use, instead of dozens inactive ones that are just a backdoor waiting to happen.
- taeric 8y agoYou are just using a different web of trust. Specifically the SSL Certificate Authorities.
- tedunangst 8y agoWhen your browser auto updates, how many key servers does it contact? How many cross signatures does it require before trusting a key?
- klodolph 8y ago> Without a web of trust, how are you securely signing? I can only think you're making a bunch of hidden assumptions about how trust works or why you would want to sign or encrypt data. Maybe you're thinking specifically about things like email, where web of trust might make more sense. Consider, for example, if I'm doing backups and I just want to encrypt them for my eyes only. How could a web of trust even possibly make sense in that scenario?
- taeric 8y agoIf you are just doing backups, why are you bothering signing something? I mean, yes. Pgp is a bad fit for that. So is tls.
- Boulth 8y agoMaybe to ensure that it was you that created the backup? It may be nice when restoring the backup.
- taeric 8y agoBut if you encrypted them, there is no reason to also sign them. Either you have the key to decrypt, thus you did it, or you don't, so you didn't. Signing is for verification of identity over potentially compromisable channels. Not securing controlled items.
- afiori 8y agoif you encrypted it with a public key then you also need a signature, I am not sure what the parent meant though.
- taeric 8y agoI'm not sure I follow. If you are decrypting with a key, either you trust it or you don't. It works or doesn't. That is, why use a public key scheme, for private encryption? It is literally made to establish identity with someone else. Not yourself. Even if you sign things for personal use, that is just to confirm nothing was tampered with. Which, if it was encrypted with a key, is already guaranteed. Otherwise it won't decrypt. Right?
- pera 8y agoI'm not sure I understand your comment, can you be more specific please? you don't have to use WoT if you don't want/need it.
- klodolph 8y agoPGP is downright user-hostile once you're not using web of trust. So it's true, that you don't have to use web of trust. But PGP goes out of its way to make your life hell. For example, let's say you have a key (as an ordinary file) and a signed message in hand. How do you check that this key has signed this message, using the gpg command-line tools? The problem with PGP is that it combines web of trust and the mechanical actions of signature verification and cryptography into one tool. It forces you to use one program both to express "trust" and to do signature verification. God forbid you should ever want to sign or encrypt something without futzing about with your keychain.
- bmn__ 8y ago> How do you check that this key has signed this message, using the gpg command-line tools? gpg2 --import pubkey.gpg gpg2 --verify-files a-message.asc
- klodolph 8y agoThis imports a key into my keychain, maybe I don't want to import this key? It also doesn't tell me if the message was signed with the key I specified, I have to do that myself, maybe by looking closely at the output? Awful, 3/10.
- throwaway415415 8y agoYou can use pgp without the web of trust. I think you are missing GP's point.
- klodolph 8y agoI think you may have misread my comment, since I never claimed it was not possible to use PGP without web of trust. I claimed that it was a pain in the ass.
- throwaway415415 8y agoIts a pain in the ass because nobody has created a user friendly UI for that, but in itself it is a powerful technique to establish trust.
- klodolph 8y agoPGP’s UI isn’t user friendly to begin with, in fact, it’s notoriously bad. But that’s not the point. You try to get PGP to verify a signature without importing the key into a keychain fist. The purported benefits of web of trust are completely irrelevant, the problem is that PGP handcuffs you to the web of trust and web of trust is often unwanted. You have to reduce and simplify your trust to something that PGP understands. There is no reason on this earth that signature verification should require importing shit into a database. The whole philosophy of “do one thing well” would be nice here. PGP never lets you do one thing, it makes you buy the whole banana.
- throwaway415415 8y agoPgp does not handcuff you to the web of trust. Actually most people who use pgp do not use the web of trust but instead compare fingerprints or do trust on first use. If you do not understand this your argument is moot. It is not because you learned in class that pgp works with the web of trust that this is what actually happens in practice