3 ms·
It's 2019 and we're still doing email based signups, by default. What's wrong with this industry? OpenId was a pretty neat idea twelve years ago. And given the
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
It's 2019 and we're still doing email based signups, by default. What's wrong with this industry? OpenId was a pretty neat idea twelve years ago. And given the amount of password databases getting compromised, quite many websites would have been better off federating identity with a competent provider. But no, world plus dog still outsources security to email providers like hotmail, gmail, or worse. Basically compromise somebody's inbox and you gain access to most of what they ever signed up for. Single point of failure, and even if you protect it properly you are still at the mercy of their support not falling for some social engineering attempts.
It would be nice if Mozilla followed through with their repeated attempts to integrate authentication in the browser (they've been experimenting with this for most of this decade) and deliver something that 1) works, 2) is stupidly easy to start using for websites, 3) is bleedingly obvious to use for end users. The current implementation of webauthn fails all 3 tests. I've not seen it work once. I rarely encounter websites that support it and it does not work with mainstream hardware like the nano ledger or now very common finger print readers on many laptops.
I've had finger print readers on my laptop for ages. I've yet to encounter a website or browser capable of doing anything productive with that. I thought webauthn was supposed to be it but it seems to be out of scope and instead require USB dongles. Even Apple, who apparently love dongles, are not bothering to support that with a dongle or other people's dongles. The first browser to do the bleedingly obvious thing to support built in fingerprint readers in combination with webauthn would instantly incentivize hordes of website developers to start relying on that. So much easier than messing with passwords. Also, MS seems to perpetually get stuck doing proprietary whatever instead of fixing security properly. Apple has been shipping touchid for a few years now. Lenovos came with fingerprint readers last decade already.
- treve 8y agoI also don't understand why Mozilla killed these projects. The original persona (BrowserID) was a pretty solid idea, but I think it's pretty expected for these things to take years of advocacy to pick up. I wonder if it was changed and canned simply because they didn't hit their early metrics.
- WorldMaker 8y agoMy (lay) reading of it was that it was indirectly killed by the FirefoxOS efforts. A lot of the enthusiastic BrowserID/Persona folks got roped into the login/auth parts of FirefoxOS. I think a lot of good enthusiasm/energy was burnt by FirefoxOS not doing well, and that burnout was accidentally/indirectly the death of BrowserID/Persona more than anything else.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sixothree 8y agoHP ProBooks have included fingerprint readers for a decade as well. It's time.
- CM30 8y agoI think you need to keep in mind a few things here: 1. Many of the things you mention are kinda complex, and many sites use CMS type setups/SaaS setups where the team creating the site doesn't have that much programming experience. 2. Browser support for novel authentication methods was lacking for a while. I read that Microsoft finally added functionality to Edge to integrate with the computer's login authentication setup, and some of the others are now doable with JavaScript, but they weren't practical there for a while. 3. Most people are still kinda confused about novel login methods, as mentioned in the article in the magic links section.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> OpenId was a pretty neat idea twelve years ago. OpenId was maybe neat except for its little fatal flaw of being a single point of failure outside your control. Your provider decides your account should be taken down and suddenly you use access to everything.
- WorldMaker 8y agoExcept OpenID was built for bloggers and you could change your account provider at anytime through URL delegation. OpenID's flaw was being built for the web where everyone had a "homepage" or "blog" just as nearly everything shifted to social media and corporate-controlled walled gardens.
- stickfigure 8y agoAlso, people just fundamentally don't think of themselves as web pages. Browserid/persona got it right with an email-esque identifier.
- zanny 8y agoWebauthn is creeping along gradually. Things like fingerprints and browser accounts should eventually be added to it as auth mechanisms and it will be glorious the day you just go to a website already signed in via your public keys that are available cross device automagically from your Mozilla / MS / Google / Apple account.
- djsumdog 8y agoI recent did a write up on the decline of OpenID: https://penguindreams.org/blog/the-decline-of-openid/ https://penguindreams.org/blog/the-decline-of-openid/ It use to use my own identity provider quite a bit, but every website that use to take OpenID no longer does. OpenID Connect is just a modified OAuth and even fewer website that custom OpenID Connect. Stackoverflow dropping it pretty much put a nail in the coffin.
- fivre 8y agoOpenID may not be particularly common in consumer-facing services, but it is very much still in use for business applications. Almost every web application I use for work handles authentication through my G Suite account. This is probably easier for the business case, where you can guarantee that everyone has an account from the same provider. Less so when some of your users want to use a Google account, some want to use Facebook (which isn't actually OIDC and requires its own separate implementation), some want to use Microsoft, etc. Like any complex open standard, the completeness and correctness of implementations vary widely, and supporting many different implementations is a pain even if 90% is the same. I'm reminded of my time working with different IPSec implementations.