6 ms·
One of those "Google is the new AOL" moments hit me when I heard a commercial for Google on the radio recently. Specifically, it was someone explaining that the
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
One of those "Google is the new AOL" moments hit me when I heard a commercial for Google on the radio recently. Specifically, it was someone explaining that they had a feature built especially for veterans to find jobs relevant to them, and that you could get to it by typing "jobs for veterans" into Google search.
It just sounded so much like the old AOL Keyword feature, which a lot of people forgot about, but was literally often advertised on TV or radio as how to get to a given site or web feature.
- bwb 8y agoI do not understand how you guys can call Google the new AOL, Google search works like a charm at a huge scale. What is the problem?
- DylanBohlender 8y agoI think the crux of the others’ point is that Google’s increasingly complex secret sauce for returning search results, combined with its general ubiquity, has perhaps created a monoculture whereby we view the Web almost entirely through Google’s lens. AOL’s “curation” of the web via its portal was a bit more direct for sure, but I can see how the effect could be similar.
- mda 8y agoOh believe me you can find all sorts of non curated filth as well using Google as well. I think it is still a pretty good engine for "if you insist, here is the path to rabbit hole". If you let google know about you, it will tune the results for you. I keep my history for this reason.
- wil421 8y agoIt’s not comparing technical merit or business decisions. AOL for a long time was the window into the web for lots of American users. Google is now a window into the web for users around the world.
- macintux 8y agoGoogle’s algorithms have the ability to make companies essentially undiscoverable, deliberately or not, so there’s at least some comparison to be made with AOL’s keyword registry.
- JohnFen 8y agoFor me, the problem is that Google doesn't work like a charm at all. It used to, but it's been consistently getting worse over the years.
- mda 8y agoExamples? Maybe your expectations grew faster than technology to keep up?
- macintux 8y agoInterestingly, that was the idea I distinctly remember from the dinner party: someone suggested the only fix for Internet searches was to implement something like AOL Keywords globally. A central registry of keywords.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoWhat would you be trying to "fix" here? More often than not, the first result for a given query on most common search engines is the correct, authoritative source for something. If I search for a company, the company's official website is nearly always the first real result. The only thing I think is really wrong with search (and all major search engines right now are guilty of this) is making paid ads look very similar to real results, which makes it possible to pay to hijack a result.
- vidarh 8y agoThey're referring to a conversation in 1994. In 1994 that was definitively not the case.
- JohnFen 8y ago> More often than not, the first result for a given query on most common search engines is the correct, authoritative source for something. I can't remember that happening in years with Google. Now, it's unusual if the thing I'm searching for even appears in the first page.
- vidarh 8y agoRealnames almost achieved that, by being added to IE: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RealNames https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RealNames