3 ms·
IMHO delaying the inevitable is not a plan. We need to find a way to survive the inevitable use and deployment of technology by others. This stuff is no longer
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
IMHO delaying the inevitable is not a plan. We need to find a way to survive the inevitable use and deployment of technology by others. This stuff is no longer rocket science. Any idiot with a raspberry pi and some basic tooling can build some quite effective weaponry. Most of the AI you need for this is OSS and getting easier to use by the month. This is not at all like nuclear warfare where you need a lot of skills, knowledge, infrastructure, and capital expenses to be able to put a weapon together. All this stuff will take is a bit of ingenuity and access to commodity hardware and software.
IMHO hoping that others won't go there is not a plan because ultimately somebody will. We need credible defensive capability against this stuff. Given the adversary is going to be autonomous AIs with lightning fast responses, having humans in the loop when defending means being defenseless effectively.
Most current wars are asymmetric guerrilla wars where there is a powerful but reluctant to engage party and some highly motivated individuals fighting an unwinnable fight. E.g. the conflicts in the middle east are basically premised on men with primitive weaponry moving around the country trying to stay hidden from air surveillance, satellites, or simply hiding among civilians. Countries like the US are reluctant to go in and fight on the ground because things get ugly in terms of casualties and 'collateral' damage. You can bet drones will be popular on both sides in such conflicts.
Drone based warfare would make that a lot more one sided than it already is and would probably make this type of warfare a lot less attractive and potentially put an end to a lot of long running conflicts. This does not have to turn into the cliche dystopian mess. For that look no further than the current state of affairs in e.g. Congo, Yemen, Afghanistan, or Syria.
War is not about chivalry but about winning at any cost. When one side is fighting with their hands behind their backs thus preventing them from winning and the other side can't win, you have a stalemate. It used to be the case that the winner would execute/enslave surviving enemies. Brutal but effective. When the war was over, there was little chance of a comeback by the other side. These days we do a lot of damage to each other but it is rarely decisive. WWII was one of the last conflicts where the other side literally had no choice but to surrender unconditionally. I live in Berlin. The effects of that war are very visible still. It's also a very peaceful city these days. That war was really over when it was over.
Wars between nation states are subject to all sorts of international rules. The problem is that most wars these days do not necessarily involve nation states and nation states instead engage each other via proxy wars. E.g. the US, Iran, and Russia are not formally at war but actively engaging each other in a plausibly deniable way nevertheless. These wars are dirty, brutal, and cause a lot of misery precisely because they rarely are fought to a conclusion and fought using any means possible.