3 ms·
Ffs, corona loss is only one small factor of transmission loss. https://electrical-engineering-portal.com/total-losses-in-power-distribution-and-transmission-li
by kortilla 8y ago
Ffs, corona loss is only one small factor of transmission loss. https://electrical-engineering-portal.com/total-losses-in-power-distribution-and-transmission-lines-1 https://electrical-engineering-portal.com/total-losses-in-po...
Ignoring that major oversight, transmission lines aren’t free and they require upkeep so building/maintaining them across the ocean needs to be factored into your costs.
It’s like claiming it’s cheaper to have sushi flown in from Japan everyday if you just ignore the air freight cost.
- ben_w 8y agoYes that was a silly omission. However, adding resistive losses doesn’t change the conclusion because the margin is so large (it does make it much closer though). And this is ignoring that the line losses we see now are based on the most cost-effective designs for nation-scale grids, when one can straightforwardly (for example) use a higher voltage for lower resistive losses (no point reducing those losses further on nation-scale grids), or even use existing medium-temperature superconductors, which is thing but not widely used for power yet. And I literally acknowledged that I was excluding the cost, financial and political, of building and maintaining the lines in my first post on this thread. I ignored those costs because my argument is, and always was, that solutions already exist. That the line losses — large as they are for a worldwide grid — are not a fundamental problem. It’s not like we can’t build pylons or have yet to invent a way to join wires together after they come out of a factory. And we already have a lot of national scale grids, how hard is to join the existing ones together? Sure, it’s a bit close when comparing 2.155 cents per kWh * 20% line efficiency (which is worse than even my updated estimate!) to fossil, but that’s also your midnight cost, when you use least.
- kortilla 8y agoIf you have the power to just throw out costs as a concern, then we’ve had a solution for much longer. Geothermal. >And we already have a lot of national scale grids, how hard is to join the existing ones together? Very. We haven’t even managed to get the US on a national grid. To connect continents is just fantasy at this point. Do you realize the undertaking it would be to get 700kv line to Hawaii, Australia, New Zealand, etc?