3 ms·
None of this has anything to do with technical problems with building nuclear reactors. The US Navy has been hiring private contractors to build them for decade
by pdonis 8y ago
None of this has anything to do with technical problems with building nuclear reactors. The US Navy has been hiring private contractors to build them for decades with no such issues. (And Naval reactors have more stringent requirements than commercial ones, because of the widely varying loads they have to deal with.)
The so-called "cost savings" in France are due to unrealistically optimistic assumptions about renewables, not any issues with nuclear.
The issues in the US are entirely legal and political: nuclear power plant projects get tied up by interminable lawsuits based on NIMBYism and ignorance, and the US political policies on fuel reprocessing have turned what should have been an easily solved problem into a quagmire.
I suspect the "problems" in China are more due to their cavalier attitude towards coal than anything else; they don't mind firing up a lot of new coal plants and having lots of people suffer respiratory disease and death as a result, if that's cheaper than nuclear.
- Maakuth 8y agoIt depends how you defined technical issue. For example the French Areva power plant projects in Europe have been met with all sorts of issues ranging from subcontractors that are inexperienced with NPP level of quality and documentation requirements all the way to challenge of proving automation system reliability to the regulatory body. These happen in the plant vendor's native France as well, so shouldn't be cultural issues either. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_(nuclear_reactor) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_(nuclear_reactor) These are not NIMBY or political issues, but rather stem from the fact that there's been a long pause in building new NPPs in the west. All the senior people involved with earlier designs are long since retired and even the juniors that were around might have moved on. And also some of the technology choices used in old designs are not even available anymore, so there's new families of tech to prove to the regulators, digital automation being one of these to my understanding.
- olau 8y agoAlso, we've seen more things go wrong. When you design a nuclear plant, you need to do a really careful risk analysis. That's why they are so safe. But as time progresses, and actual designs meet reality and Murphy's law kicks it, it turns out some of the assumptions are factually incorrect. More elaborate safety requirements are needed to compensate, increasing cost. You can't build a car the way you could 50 years ago, and the same is true for nuclear plants.
- jessaustin 8y agoWhy don't we just buy a few of those Navy reactors and hook them to the grid?
- pfdietz 8y agoThey wouldn't be close to competitive.
- jessaustin 8y agoI assumed as much; that's the point.
- dv_dt 8y agoNavy reactors have completely different design parameters, one of which is the use weapons grade fuel...