3 ms·
What is the danger here? There are kids making more money on youtube doing other things. Is this sexual? Because nearly anything can be sexual for someone.
by sandworm101 8y ago
What is the danger here? There are kids making more money on youtube doing other things. Is this sexual? Because nearly anything can be sexual for someone. Some are excited by people popping balloons. The only complete answer is to ban kids from youtube, and that isnt going to happen.
Before going after asmr, take a close look at who watches the gymnastics and cheerleading "demos". Pole dancing is also now a sport for kids. That is on youtube too.
I once taught a law class where we had to discuss this stuff. If you take away every "sexualized" image of an under-18 you are blacklisting huge areas of modern culture, everything from family sitcoms to superhero movies. Some disney movies have scenes that are shocking when you play them on thier own, many ironically on youtube... which made playing them during lectures much easier on me.
- Zenbit_UX 8y agoInteresting that HN is just hearing about this, it made the front page of reddit back in October when a youtuber named wubbey "investigated" it. His video is both funny and hard to watch due to the extremely awkward sexual undertones. So to answer your question, is this sexual? Yes, and that seems to be the intent of whoever is running that channel. See for yourself: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M78rlxEMBxk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M78rlxEMBxk
- sandworm101 8y agoThis issue comes up all the time: is it sexual per se, ie for everyone, or does the viewer make it sexual? Balloons are not sexual. They only become so in the mind of certain viewers. Is asmr always sexual, or does it only become so because a kid is involved? That might say more about the viewer than the material. Without clarity, if there is room for debate, i side with not restricting the speech rights of these kids.
- Rebelgecko 8y agoOut of curiosity did you watch the linked video? This isn't "Pizzagate" looking for pedophilia where it doesn't exist. The girl posted a video titled "sassy cop roleplay" featuring dialog that sounds like it came from a traffic stop in a cheesy 90s porno, but updated with Tinder references. It's not illegal bit that doesn't mean that YouTube has to host it. They've certainly deleted and demonetized videos for less.
- sandworm101 8y agoYa, but that is nothing compared to some of the other vids on youtube. Teenagers make and post crazy stuff every day. I am very hesitant to start pointing fingers at behavior that in other context our culture openly encourages and rewards. I dont like it, but it is the sort of thing best left to parents imho. I had some girls at my door last halloween dressed as harley quin. If thier parents are ok with it then im not going to say a word. Imho they looked less sexy than literaly very cold.
- kgwxd 8y agoHN is just hearing about it now because it made it to the front page of HN, but HN should never have heard about this.
- taytus 8y agoIDK if it is sexual or not, it wasn't for me but it did freaked me out a bit TBH... I mean https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wi9Ils2OA0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wi9Ils2OA0 is so stupid... or maybe I'm the stupid one.