No - because the percentages are only for withdrawn papers. The likelihood of publishing fake results should be based on the total number of papers. If the US

No - because the percentages are only for withdrawn papers. The likelihood of publishing fake results should be based on the total number of papers. If the US group had fewer withdrawn papers as a percentage of submitted papers then the 33% of withdrawn papers could amount to a smaller percentage of the total submitted than the Asians' 25%.