3 ms·
The idea is that we're in "Puzzle World". This is one of the things that most people take for granted, that the way this is set up has the ring being rigid, ev
by ColinWright 8y ago
The idea is that we're in "Puzzle World". This is one of the things that most people take for granted, that the way this is set up has the ring being rigid, even though that's not genuinely feasible. We assume that in the same way as we are assuming that the Earth is a perfect, homogeneous sphere.
I might add a note to that effect - thanks for highlighting this.
Added in edit: I've now added a note to the page to address this question/issue. And when I say "address", I really mean "try to avoid".
- noir_lord 8y agoYep, sometimes a good puzzle needs a spherical chicken to be tractable.
- ColinWright 8y agoI think you mean spherical cow ... But yes. To avoid adding yet another semi-off-topic comment in the thread I'll add this here: Yes, absolutely, "Spherical [cow|chicken|horse|other]." Cheers!
- noir_lord 8y agoThere are variants of the joke for both spherical cows and chickens going back decades. > "Postulate a spherical chicken ...", as presented in a 1973 letter to the editor of the journal Science titled A Spherical Chicken. Turing discussed spherical horses even earlier :).
- Symmetry 8y agoThere's nothing wrong with an infeasible thought experiment. Frictionless surfaces and spherical cows are a staple of learning physics. The problem is when the author describes them as "greased surfaces" or "watermellon shaped cows" and asks you to treat them as perfectly frictionless or spherical. Describing the rope as being "steel" instead of "rigid" is just needlessly confusing.
- ColinWright 8y agoIf you're inside the world of physics, "rigid" carries exactly the meaning you say it has. But it's a code word, it's got a technical meaning, and for people not in the world of physics, using the word "rigid" would, I think, be confusing. So I've updated the side-box to try to make it clearer. You might like to check it out to see what you think.