4 ms·
At least we can, (in theory) vote out our government. If I am not a shareholder, there is nothing I can do to stop a big company’s bad behavior, and if I am a s
by ryandrake 8y ago
At least we can, (in theory) vote out our government. If I am not a shareholder, there is nothing I can do to stop a big company’s bad behavior, and if I am a shareholder, then my interests align with the big company’s bad behavior.
Perhaps over a certain size, companies should be somehow required to provide the public some amount of voting power on their board, absent a financial interest in the company’s results.
- JoshTriplett 8y ago> If I am not a shareholder, there is nothing I can do to stop a big company’s bad behavior Choose not to do business with them. Advocate that others not do business with them. Encourage employees to leave or change things. Work with companies you can influence to avoid doing business with them. Create competition, whether as a business or as a new technology that obsoletes theirs. There are many, many things you can do that have far more likelihood of enacting meaningful change, and that have nothing to do with being a shareholder. The likelihood of success in such methods depends heavily on the ability to get others to agree with you and take action.
- whatislovecraft 8y ago> Choose not to do business with them This has no effect whatsoever. You can try but it won't matter. You make money for Facebook and Google even if you spend every waking hour trying not to do so. Your very existence - that you have opinions, ideas, that you go places, spend money, etc- is sufficient for these businesses to choose to do "business" with you without your knowledge. They'll take things you thought were yours and then use that to sell ads to other companies. > Advocate that others not do business with them. Again, this won't matter one bit. This kind of change takes decades to propagate throughout society, way slower than is necessary to avoid damage done. > ... > The likelihood of success in such methods depends heavily on the ability to get others to agree with you and take action. So none of your ideas will work. The 'markets' are broken when looking at long-term financial gain through sustainable growth and consumer choice. Do not look to broken-since-inception-on-purpose "models" to dictate how you think a modern economy should function.
- JoshTriplett 8y ago> So none of your ideas will work. Your dismissal is not a counterargument. These approaches have worked in the past, multiple times, with many different companies, to enact change. They may or may not work every time. And on the flip side, in some cases not everyone will agree that they should work. Your position of what should happen to these companies is not necessarily a universal position.
- whatislovecraft 8y ago> Your dismissal is not a counterargument. Oh sorry, I didn't mean to dismiss. I was trying to say that if your conclusion/mechanism to enact change depends on the success of convincing individual people do take action, it is unlikely to succeed for these reasons: - People converse slowly, especially on awkward topics like privacy. Opinions change slowly. - Propaganda and willingness of huge corporations to try to alter public opinion is huge, growing and already very intense. There is little historical analogue for it because so much power is concentrated so tightly now, with tools that completely change the balance of power (like AI, big data analytics, etc). > They may or may not work every time. Right. But we only have 1 shot at this and it needs to work. Our systems have already failed and our society is suffering because of it. Our government is not stable, our emotions are proudly directly manipulated by corporations, and we are hurting because of it. We must regulate because we cannot afford future losses of this magnitude.
- JoshTriplett 8y ago> - People converse slowly, especially on awkward topics like privacy. Opinions change slowly. And yet you're suggesting government regulation that moves more quickly, which implies that the government shouldn't wait that conversation and consensus to happen. (Leaving aside whether the government should do it even if people do support it, it certainly seems even worse to do it if there isn't such a consensus.) > But we only have 1 shot at this and it needs to work. You are presuming agreement with your premise. And you are furthermore presuming that the resulting regulation will work, and will not cause worse damage. (And where does "only have one shot at this" come from, here?) "The government should exert control over one of the most popular communications mediums" is a terrifying proposition, with the potential to support a huge amount of damage. I don't think it's a given that that damage would be less than the problem it's trying to solve.