3 ms·
> I wonder how many actually trust this government with more power? No matter someone's political views, it surprises me when people are willing to trust the g
by JoshTriplett 8y ago
> I wonder how many actually trust this government with more power?
No matter someone's political views, it surprises me when people are willing to trust the government with more power as long as their party is in control, while forgetting that their party will not always be in control. Before assigning a new power to government, consider whether you'd trust the opposing party to wield it.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoThe thing is, the government already has the power! Congress can pass any laws it likes, the president can try to veto, and the courts will decide what's legit or not. "Trusting this government with more power" is totally outside your control.
- JoshTriplett 8y ago> "Trusting this government with more power" is totally outside your control. When you fight to pass a law that will create new government institutions and regulations and grow it in size, you're advocating the granting of more power to government. You are in control of whether you choose to advocate that or whether you choose to say "this could be abused". Government is the ultimate example of needing to consider yourself part of the threat model of your system.
- CM30 8y agoForget the future, some people seem to be making that mistake with an opposing government right now. How many people do you see on the 'left' of the political spectrum wanting the government to regulate 'fake news' or 'social media' or 'the internet' while forgetting that it's Donald Trump and co in power right now? You already see full well how much the government disagrees with its critics on what's considered fake news or not. Don't they realise it'd probably be pro Breitbart/pro Infowars regulation there, with the main targets being those outlets they support? Same goes for this social media regulation stuff. You won't get a crackdown on 'Russian propaganda', since the elected government over in the US does't believe it is an issue at all. Government agencies don't stay very independent either, and even if they do, you have no guarantee they'll do what you think is right at all. See net neutrality and Ajit Pai. So yeah, their party won't always be in control and in a lot of cases, their party isn't in control right now anyway.
- fzeroracer 8y agoIf that was honestly the case, new laws and regulations would never get passed as you fear both sides abusing them to further their own goals. It only furthers the goals of those who believe the government should be destroyed to employ gridlock because over time regulations will be erased with nothing to replace them. For some things I would trust the government over states. If Gay Marriage was left up to the states, there would still be a large amount of states that would gladly ban it. Yet people feared any sort of laws or regulations surrounding gay marriage being passed as a way of the government usurping power.
- JoshTriplett 8y ago> For some things I would trust the government over states. I would certainly consider federal regulations saying "states may not prevent X" (and in turn state regulations saying "cities may not prevent X") a good thing. That's not an increase in power, that's an intentional ceding of power.
- a_imho 8y agoIt surprises me people think along the lines of parties, particularly more often than not 2 parties: us and them.