4 ms·
No, because then it's a race to the bottom and all other companies start expecting these same deals (or even better), and eventually you do end up with a situat
by CydeWeys 8y ago
No, because then it's a race to the bottom and all other companies start expecting these same deals (or even better), and eventually you do end up with a situation where the city does not get back more in tax revenue.
It's simple negotiation; you may lose some money on that one deal, but you'll gain more in the end by not decreasing the value of all subsequent deals.
- natalyarostova 8y agoThe counter-point to race to the bottom, is this is an important aspect of pressure in a democratic capitalism to prevent government as a leviathan. The government has a natural incentive to want to raise more revenue, and increase power. A strong market that can stifle these, at times potentially inefficient taxes, can provide a natural check on this. Obviously the truth is that there are bad aspects of a race to the bottom as well as positive attributes. Finding the balance requires nuance and grace by the leaders who navigate these uncertain waters.
- refurb 8y agoIf a city signs up for a money losing deal, that’s on them. They should have negotiated better.
- SilasX 8y agoOr, you'll lose out on all the businesses that won't start or expand there because the baseline level of taxation is too unfavorable for the economy (in either sense of the word) that the city offers. It's almost like taxing easily-moveable economic activity is a bad idea.
- CydeWeys 8y agoAnd yet there's a huge number of businesses that do have presences in NYC because the tax revenue funds all sorts of things that make NYC attractive to businesses that can't be gotten elsewhere. A lot of what makes NYC great (like the 24/7 public transit system, the best in the country) costs serious money to operate. You need to get that money from tax revenue. And businesses aren't actually easily-movable, not at all.
- SilasX 8y ago>And yet there's a huge number of businesses that do have presences in NYC because the tax revenue funds all sorts of things that make NYC attractive to businesses that can't be gotten elsewhere. Most of which were present there because they set up a long time ago. The current environment makes it so that you pretty much have to get a discount to make it worth starting there, per the famous reddit comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/9wploz/ocasiocortez_blasts_tax_breaks_for_amazon_says/e9mdind/ https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/9wploz/ocasiocortez_bl... >And businesses aren't actually easily-movable, not at all. "Where they decide to locate new offices" is.
- throwawaysea 8y agoWhat's the problem with governments competing? That's not a "race to the bottom" any more than competition is a "race to the bottom" in market economics. It is a forcing function on efficiency and good governance where there would otherwise be no competitive pressure.
- bduerst 8y ago^ For anyone doubting this, Planet Money did an excellent podcast on how this phenomenon played out in Kansas City with corporations like Applebee's, and cost the city millions: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/11/16/668769284/episode-699-kansas-city-vs-kansas-city https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2018/11/16/668769284/epis...
- ApolloFortyNine 8y agoYou could easily argue it put Kansas City on the map. Kansas City is at least a well known name in the tech world now, when there's plenty of other midwest cities of similar size that rarely get brought up. Millions would be a steal for the revenue becoming a tech hub would bring in. Even if it does take a more than a decade to be realized.
- meesterdude 8y agoNews to me kansas city is popular in the tech world now.
- ApolloFortyNine 8y agoI didn't say popular. Cities of similar size: Albuquerque, Milwaukee, Louisville, Oklahoma City (and more). Out of these, Kansas City comes up more often tech wise. I waste a good bit of time on sites like this discussing tech related matters, and not once have I read an article involving any of these cities. This is why I said well known and on the map, not 'popular'.
- bduerst 8y agoHow did giving Applebee's a tax discount put KC on the map for tech?