4 ms·
> The state of California treats capital gains just like any other income, levying a 13.3 percent state tax on sales of stock. For someone sitting on tens of mi
by AlexandrB 8y ago
> The state of California treats capital gains just like any other income, levying a 13.3 percent state tax on sales of stock. For someone sitting on tens of millions of dollars in private stock — life-changing money for some — it’s not a small concern.
Yes, it literally is! It's 13% - that's about the same as sales tax in many places and nowhere near AOC's 70% tax. This is greed, plain and simple. 99% of the world would do almost anything to have this "problem".
- tenpies 8y agoAnd 99% of the world would act in the same way if they had the luxury of that problem. I understand why Leftist populists love attributing some sort of exceptional immorality to the wealthy, but people act on incentives. Give them an incentive to leave and they will leave.
- octonion 8y agoIf you live in California, you obey California laws or you go to California jail. If you don't agree with what California has decided is necessary for a healthy society, you have states like Mississippi and Louisiana to choose from. Good luck finding a high-paying job there.
- lightedman 8y ago"Good luck finding a high-paying job there." I guess you have no clue what jobs actually exist in those states. They're the same jobs that exist in every other state. Then to boot, there are plenty of high-paying jobs which exist in those states which generally do not exist in many others, like offshore oil rig jobs.
- Jhndb 8y agoOr all the other states with plenty of high paying tech jobs
- chrshawkes 8y agoRidiculous comment. I live in VA and we're doing quite well thank you. Silicon Valley incomes without the state corruption. Our problem is electing a decent governor apparently. I'll take VA over California every time.
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoNonsense. They just send collectors after you unless the delinquency is epic in scale, and even then, they just send better collectors after you unless you show some kind of contempt. What a bizarre mentality. Enjoy having a large portion of your 'high paying job' eaten up by real estate costs and taxes while people who move out of CA laugh at you all the way to the bank.
- EpicEng 8y agoI'm enjoying my high paying job in Austin while paying no state income tax, thanks. Moved from SD two years ago, it's great.
- larrywright 8y agoSee, the thing is the cost of living in those states is actually reasonable. It doesn’t cost $1M for a “starter home”. So we don’t need a “high paying job”, we just need one that pays a reasonable amount. Also, by all accounts CA doesn’t have a healthy society. (for the record, I don’t live in the states you mocked, but I live in Illinois which has a similar cost of living)
- at-fates-hands 8y ago> Good luck finding a high-paying job there. Kansas has the lowest cost of living in the country. You don't need to have a high paying job to be living like a king. I remember having a two bedroom apartment to myself and paying around $500/month. My two friends who settled there found 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom houses for under $300K. They were able to put down around $40K and had a monthly mortgage of around 1K. They were both in the tech sector there and were making around 80K each which is pretty low compared to SV or other states, but because the cost of living was so low, they were living rather comfortable.
- sigi45 8y agoOr someone who has already a shitton of money just stop trying to get the most out of it Everytime.
- kristianc 8y agoQuite - Leftists reframe the question "Why do you need that money?" when the one we should be asking is "Why is the state entitled to it?"
- untog 8y agoBecause very often the answer is "the state enabled you to earn that money in the first place, moving things on its roads, and employing workers educated by its school system, while under the protection of its police force and fire service"
- vidarh 8y agoI find it enlightening to discuss with people what they would do if they could unilaterally secede. I find offering the option quite appealing, in the sense that it would hold government strictly to account if it annoys sufficiently large minorities to warrant large splits. But what the people opposing taxes often tends to forget is that if you want to argue that society should be organized in a fully voluntary way, then the rest of society don't owe you access to any of their public services either if you're not prepared to agree to their terms for interacting with you. If someone is ok with taking the consequences of that, then, hey, let them, but in my experience the moment you point out the likely consequences, there is a tendency to start crying about how unfair it would be when other people want to exercise their freedoms to refuse to deal with someone not prepared to pay their share. In other words, most of this boils down to wanting to be free to pick and choose how they interact with wider society, without wanting the rest of society to be able to pick and choose how to interact with them.
- skh 8y agoYour question is just as bad. Here’s the framing I prefer. 1. Government is necessary since some things are best run by public services and without a for-profit motive. 2. What are these things? 3. How much money should be raised to properly run these things? 4. What is the optimum tax rate/policy to achieve this goal?
- 8y ago
- justin66 8y ago> people act on incentives. Give them an incentive to leave and they will leave. This is a very silly statement. The small fraction of people who leave has increased a little bit in size.
- vidarh 8y agoBelgium has the highest tax burden of any OECD country. According to OECDs annual Taxing Wages report for 2017, Belgiums total tax wedge for an average earner (the total tax wedge includes employers payroll taxes) was 54%, compared to an OECD average of 36% (US is at 31.7%). The direct "employee visible" part of that is 40.7% vs an OECD average of 25.5% (US 26%). Based on your line of thinking, people should be fleeing Belgium in huge numbers. Belgium is in the EU and has land borders with Germany, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and France. Germany is not far off in taxes, but France is at 29.1%, Luxembourg at 31%, the Netherlands at 30.4%. Anyone with Belgian citizenship can work and live in any of these countries without having to apply for any visa or work permit. (so far that also applies to the UK, over the channel, but given Brexit I ignored it) Most Belgians speak French or Dutch, so language should not stop them. Yet, despite these rather significant monetary incentives to even move across the border, within a short driving distance from their current location, to countries with the same language, there is somehow not a massive amount of Belgians fleeing the country. Note that this is tax burden for an average tax payer. Not marginal rates paid by the very few. In other words: Sure, people act on incentives, but unsurprisingly peoples decisions about where to live are not only down to a few percentage points of taxation. Some will move, many won't, and yes, that is something to take into account when setting tax policies.
- zdragnar 8y ago> AOC's 70% tax Also doesn't apply to capital gains.
- seattle_spring 8y agoAlso only would apply to income over $10 million.
- influx 8y agoIsn’t capital gains what drives most billionaires wealth? Last I recall, Jeff Bezos has a salary under 100k, and the rest is from stock.
- kuhhk 8y ago>It's 13% - that's about the same as sales tax in many places No, not really.. You're free to choose states with sensible department of revenues. Wyoming has a 4-6% sales tax, nowhere near the 13% you're arguing about. If capgains of 13% is levied upon 10mil, that's 1.3mil.... while Wyoming's 4-6% sales tax is (obviously less than half that) only levied upon actual purchases (which in practice is way lower).
- jfk13 8y agoIf I'd hit the startup jackpot and found myself with $10M of stock, and wanted to turn it into cash, I think I could afford $1.3M of tax. The remaining $8.7M would keep me pretty comfortable for now.
- splendidtube 8y agoExcept that is just state tax. Add in federal and you’re looking at a combined 50%.
- cmpolis 8y agoThat's just the bill for state tax (need to consider federal, property, sales tax)
- vidarh 8y ago> No, not really.. Seeing as they're talking about 99% of the world elsewhere, it is reasonable to consider sales tax and VAT other than just the US. The vast majority of the worlds population live in countries with VAT rates at or above 13% Only 3 European countries have VAT rates below 17% (Liechtenstein, Andorra and Switzerland). 19 countries in the Americas have VAT rates at 13% or above. 16 Asian countries (including China and India) have VAT rates at 13% or above. Only 8 of 55 African countries have VAT below 13% Most also have capital gains tax and dividend taxes well over 13%
- castlecrasher2 8y agoIs the article disagreeing with you, or are you saying a couple millions of dollars taxed on a stock sale is, in fact, a small concern?
- insickness 8y agoIt's not greed to want to keep your money from an already over-bloated bureaucratic government. On one hand, people complain about government authority and then those same people are happy to grow the government as large and powerful as possible, both through taxes and regulation. Then they cry foul when that double-edged sword is used by people like Trump to do things they don't like.
- sdinsn 8y ago> near AOC's 70% tax ...For the highest tax bracket.