3 ms·
My impression is that most schools don't like accelerating kids, because they can end up way too young among much older class mates in a completely different ph
by mcv 8y ago
My impression is that most schools don't like accelerating kids, because they can end up way too young among much older class mates in a completely different phase of their lives. The Dougie Howser idea is terrible; Dougie is not a doctor, he's a child and should get the chance to live as one.
Better is challenging children in other areas: find things outside the regular school curriculum to challenge them with. Robotics, philosophy, science, politics, or other projects that are interesting and challenging but don't make them bored about next year's school curriculum.
My son did skip a grade despite his school not being a fan, and he did so at a point where next year's curriculum would have been mostly a repetition of the previous year's. That would have been a recipe for boredom, so it makes sense to skip that. But other than that, he just does a bit extra in less time and gets other interesting challenging stuff to keep him occupied.
When I was a kid, my schools did nothing of the sort, and I ended up bored and demotivated. By the time I went to university, I still hadn't learned to do homework, because I never needed to. Turns out being able to work is rather an important skill in university. I plan to make sure my son learns it on time. But not by skipping too many grades.
- MRD85 8y agoThe phase of the life issue is touched upon in the link. It discusses how the accelerated kids are often happy because they have new peers who have similar interests. It's a difficult issue to solve. A 7-year-old who is 4 years ahead of his age group peers has little in common with his peer group but is very much younger than 11-year-olds. The study in the link appears to indicate that the accelerated kids ended up happier and more fulfilled as adults. I think that's a very good argument for acceleration.